Tides of War
I arrived the morning of the battle, in the train with Telamon and our Messenians, so wretched with septic fever that I must be borne on a wagon with the infants, the pregnant camp wives, and the spare spearshafts.
I had never seen so many troops, and of such quality. Once as lads, Lion and I had larked after the runners in the torch race of the Panathenaea. From the statue of Love in the Academy where the competitors light their brands, we paced with them through the Sacred Gate, across the agora, past the Altar of the Twelve Gods, lapping the Acropolis to the Heracleum, every foot of which thronged with humanity. That was nothing beside Mantinea. The entire army of Argos stood to hand, led by their elite, the Thousand, along with the corps of Mantinea, regiment after regiment, the Cleonaeans and Orneaeans, the allies and hired troops of Arcadia, with a thousand heavy infantry of Athens, dispatched in “defensive posture,” so as not to poach upon the Peace. Further, it seemed, every jack of the Argolid who could hurl a dart or sling a stone had collected, making five and six light-armed for every heavy infantryman.
We crossed with our Messenians behind the marshaling troops. I was sick and puking like a dog. I must arm, however, or never face my mates again. I was just commencing, abetted by Eunice, when Lion reined in above. He bore a courier’s pennant and trailed a second mount, a mare which, he reported, had thrown her rider.
I must mount as a dispatch runner. Such office, at Alcibiades’ orders, would not be left this day to pages but only officers. Alcibiades was on-site not as a commander (he had failed of election this term to the Board of Generals at Athens), but only as an envoy. Such distinctions were academic, of course, as any post he held became the hub and marrow simply by his occupation of it. Here was how the battle kicked off:
There had been a false start three days prior, a full-dress advance aborted by Agis a stone’s toss before contact. The Spartans had withdrawn south to Tegea. No one knew what they were up to. Attempting to flood the plain, the allies heard. The month was Boedromion; there wasn’t a course strong as an old man’s piss in either river. A day passed; then another. The allies took fright that Agis would pull something truly harebrained. They came down off Mount Alesion, an impregnable position, into the throat of the plain, just north of the Pelagos wood. Word came that the Spartans were advancing from the south with every spit and jigger they could carry. That was when I arrived. The allies had formed up, two miles across, barring the plain.
Now a fresh rumor started: the Spartans had turned back. There would be no battle; our side would haul out too. The regiment above which my brother and I perched had marshaled beneath pear trees, the only crop left untorched by the Spartans because they were not ripe, and the troops from boredom had begun gnawing the stony culls. These made men crap like geese. By twos and threes troops fell from formation, ostensibly to heed nature’s call but in truth to get a jump on packing for decampment.
Suddenly one saw dust.
Wisps ascended from the Pelagos wood a mile away. This appeared at first as the brush-burning in fall, when the olive grovers rake their piles beneath the canopy and light them off. Now tendrils grew to vapors, and vapors to clouds. All stir ceased within our formation. The front of dust broadened; isolated risers conjoined. The tread of thirty thousand could not raise such a storm; the enemy must be twice that. Yet one saw neither a flash off a shield nor even a scout rider cantering in the fore. Just dust, ascending in thunderheads from the canopy of oak until the wood seemed to smoke from end to end.
Lion reined beside me; we must make to the commanders to receive orders. He began directing me to the swiftest track. Suddenly, inexplicably, our troops began to advance.
You have witnessed such movements in hosts of men. Soldiers in massed formation often cannot hear even a legitimate signal, owing to various clamors of the field. The individual finds himself stepping off in response to the motion of others, knowing no more why he follows than a sheep or a goose. At any event the corps began to move. “Get to the fore.” My brother motioned me toward the plain. “Find out what the hell’s going on!”
I have said I am no equestrian. More, the mare was rank; as I sought to heel her through the milling troops she began to caper and buck. The formation was among orchards, as I said, with branches abounding to crack one’s skull, not to say a forest of elevated spearpoints as my mount plunged past, while my knees and ankles clamped her in a death grip and both fists clawed into her mane. Beast and rider broke into the clear.
From Pelagos the first columns of the foe now emerged. We learned later that the Spartans had been startled nearly witless, issuing from the wood, by the sudden apparition of the allied army drawn up before them. Such was the brilliance of their discipline, however, and the order with which they deployed from column of march to line of battle, that it was we and not they who nearly buckled with terror.
I turned back to our side, the estate of Euctemon, whoever he was, who owned the land upon which the allied armies had marshaled. Here they came, left and right but no middle. Two corps advanced, with half a mile of daylight between. By the gods, what a mess!
Enemy regiments continued unpeeling from the wood. One discovered in aftermath the extent of the Spartan mobilization. So grave was the perceived threat engineered by Alcibiades that the foe had called up seven of eight age-classes, eight thousand Spartiates under both kings, Agis and Pleistoanax, with the full Corps of Knights and four of five ephors present as serving officers. In addition they had activated the forces of the seventy Lacedaemonian towns, twenty thousand heavy infantry, constrained to “follow the Spartans whithersoever they shall lead,” with the whole army of Tegea defending native soil, the Arcadian allies of Heraea and Maenalia, plus the freed helots, the brasidioi, and the “new citizens,” the neodamodeis. With the Argives, Mantineans, and allies arrayed in opposition, this was the mightiest massing of Greek against Greek in history.
Now I saw Alcibiades. Even at a distance one knew him by the dash with which he rode. The allied center at last emerged, with him and other officers galloping to join the commanders in the fore.
The full body of the foe had emerged from the wood, fifteen hundred yards off. On the flat between the armies one could see materializing, as preceding all battles, boys afoot and on ponies, and even girls come to lark and goggle. Some, caught up in the moment, would dash onto the field and lose their lives; others would prove heroes, recovering the fallen; while yet more would linger to loot the corpses of the slain. One heard the cries of dogs. The wild packs can smell a battle, and even tame hounds, whipped to a pitch by that keening heard only by their race, may be driven from the field by naught but their own extinction. I galloped toward the commanders. One could see them unnerved by the foe’s impeccable advance. “Let it be now!” Alcibiades called above the approaching din. “Let it be now!”
The foe’s skirmishers led, an eighth mile off. Lion hauled in beside me. The first sling bullets started chewing divots at our feet; in moments stones began clattering like hail. I could not reach the commanders, scattering to their units. We must fight as cavalry now, my brother shouted. Here came our own darters and lancers, packs of them on the scamper, and to the rear the mass of the heavy infantry, Argives, Mantineans and Athenians, Orneaeans and Cleonaeans, and the mercenary Arcadians. The plain trembled beneath their tread. They had commenced the paean, the same Hymn to Castor their Doric kinsmen, the Spartans, would take up in moments.
At the right of the field twined a dry course and the wreckage of a vineyard torched earlier by the foe. Over these razed walls advanced the Spartan Sciritae, eighty shields across and eight deep, whose place of honor is ever on the left. Adjacent pressed another sixteen hundred scarlet cloaks, the regiments who had fought in Thrace under Brasidas; they and the new citizens, two hundred shields more bearing the lambda of Lacedaemon.
On their right came the Corps of Peers. There was no mistaking the precision of their order and the brilliance of their kit. Every other nation of Greece advances to battle beneath
the trumpet; only Spartans employ the pipes. These now skirled that cadenced wail which is part music and part curdling of the blood. Agis the king marched at the center, flanked by the Three Hundred, the agema of Knights. The entire force, all seven regiments, strode in scarlet with their shields at march port and spears, unsheathed nine-footers, at the upright.
Across the air came “Advance to Battle.” The beat picked up and the corps as one lifted its voice in the Hymn to Nike. The formation, shields straked solid, rolled out onto the flat of the plain. I clutched my mare’s mane and kicked her like hell.
On came the line of lambdas. The Mantineans who must clash with them had worked themselves into a state of frenzy. Fear drove them to shout and beat their shields; out front their officers sought in vain to check the discomposure. Four hundred yards now separated the armored infantry. The allied line kept edging right, as armies will, as each individual seeks the shelter of the shield of the man at his shoulder, so that our wing overlapped the Spartans by an eighth of a mile. An order pealed down their line; the pipers picked it up; the Sciritae went to echelon left, fanning to conform to the oncoming Mantineans. A gap opened between them and the adjacent companies. Something had got cockeyed. No reserves advanced to fill the break. The Sciritae commanders, perceiving their vulnerability, piped back to the right. Too late. A hundred yards remained. Spears lowered to the attack. With a cry the Mantineans closed ranks and fell upon the Spartan left.
Of all moments of concentrated fury in this long and bitter war, few surpassed this, as the corps of Mantinea, fighting for home and country against that race which had lorded it over them for centuries, descended upon this blood foe, while the isolated left of Sciritae and brasidioi set shoulder by shoulder and dug in to endure the scrum of the othismos.
My brother and I were on the extreme right, with the cavalry and the overlapped heavy infantry of Mantinea. The Spartan left had been cut off on both sides, to their right by the void between themselves and the Corps of Peers, to the left by the lapped wing of the Mantineans. Here is the posture a fighting force fears most—envelopment.
Slingers and javelineers of both sides, who had been passed over by the heavy troops in the advance, now flooded into the gaps, assaulting each other and the compacted infantry. They were so close to the fight, the darters, that they flung their shafts over the shoulders of their comrades, into the faces of the foe, while across, the same dish was being served hot to them. Clouds of missiles arced and ascended, plunging and vanishing within battlements of dust. The Mantinean heavy infantry swept past Lion and me, as triremes on the sea in that maneuver called the “breakthrough,” shooting the Spartan line and doubling back to take it from flank and rear. The enemy wing, doubled upon itself, resisted with spectacular gallantry. But the mass of the Mantineans, ten thousand against fewer than five, drove them under. The foe bellied rearward. Fusillades rained upon their shivered ranks, while the heavy armor of Mantinea heaved and rammed, thirty and forty men deep. Such a cry of joy erupted as the Mantineans, so long overawed by these masters of the Peloponnese, forecast for an instant the overthrow of Sparta entire. It seemed in that moment as if nothing could stop it.
The allies drove the Sciritae back across the dry course and into the trees, all the way to the Spartan camp where the older men and the baggage train awaited. They burned this and slaughtered all they could lay hands on.
The warrior must resist now that dislocation which in the flush of apparent victory dissevers him from self-command. I found my brother and reined beside him. Our own archers were shooting at us and the other friendly cavalry, purely from elation and the prospect of such juicy targets. “We have to get over!” Lion shouted, meaning to the left of the field, where our Athenian troops and cavalry fought. We rallied what horsemen we could and set out.
A rack of defiles impeded our passage; light troops ranged like locusts. The field stood choked with smoke and dust. Mounting a rise, we expected to see the central corps clashing. Instead the expanse sprawled vacant, populated only by scattered wounded of Mantinea and Argos. We peered right, seeking the Spartans in flight. There was nothing.
We spun left. Already half a mile gone could be seen the rear ranks of the Corps of Peers, Agis, the Knights, and the seven regiments. They were driving the Argives as dogs drive sheep. What struck terror was the pitiless precision of the Spartan advance. Neither ravening nor keening as other armies in the rush of triumph, but in order, pressing steadily, relentlessly forward. As stalks of grain submit to the scythe, so did the allies fall before the Spartan advance. Their center was a half mile across, victorious along its entire length.
I heard a cry at my shoulder. A rider crumpled and pitched. Sling bullets screamed past our ears. The foe’s skirmishers, no longer in companies but a disordered host, rushed at us on the hinter ground. Our pack bolted; again my mount balked. Lion wheeled to my aid. We could see the mob of men and boys dashing upon us, while their bolts and missiles tore past with the sound of rending fabric.
We got to a ditch, but mounting the far wall, my mare tumbled. I hit teeth-first with the beast spilling atop me. My brother had breasted the bank and spurred on. From the brink the foe poured stones and darts. To my astonishment the mare returned. She was a warhorse! I clawed onto her back, which was lacerated in more places than my own. But the sheer bank undid us. Three boys had got within the ditch; they were slingers and too close to fire; instead they rushed and backed, bawling profanities as they sought to hamstring the mare with their sickles and foul her legs with the straps of their slings. Rarely have I experienced such terror, looking into those urchin eyes mad for my blood. My brother thundered from nowhere to preserve me, he and our pack from the right of the field. The mare flew from the trench. “You’re supposed to ride the horse, not the other way round!” Lion roared as we fled.
The far left was where our countrymen were, and the cavalry with Alcibiades. We must reach them, if only to die at their side. But the ground as if sown with dragon’s teeth birthed yet more skirmishers. We were sitting ducks, up high. Damn me if I ever climb on a horse again! Suddenly the main Spartan corps reversed and countermarched. One of those implausible moments of war now eventuated. The foe broke off pursuit of the Argives and Orneaeans and came about to assist its own routed countrymen of the left. This preserved us, the erstwhile horse of that quarter, from the slingers who ravened upon our track. Massed Spartan armor swept past, interdicting our pursuers. The Corps of Peers are of course all heavy infantry; on horseback we were out of their reach. Past they surged, close enough to read the details on their unit guidons and see the men’s eyes within their sockets of bronze.
On the left our Athenians had been routed too; the infantry had long fled, leaving the cavalry to range the overrun ground, defending the wounded as best they could. I saw Alcibiades’ horse, dead in the dirt, and farther in a ditch his helmet.
It struck with the clarity of revelation that our nation could not survive his loss. Perhaps this distress was fatigue-spawned. Surely my bowels and belly had been void for hours. Strength had fled both arms from grappling all day with this wild beast, upon whose back the pounding had sapped the last from my hams and knees. And yet, with that lucidity that comes at the end of one’s strength, this fear for our commander seemed valid utterly.
I must find him. Must preserve him. Up and down the courses I drove my rank mare, whose name I never learned and never care to, seeking Alcibiades.
I could not find him. Only in camp, when descent of night had at last adjourned the struggle, did he emerge from the field, in infantryman’s armor, which he had stripped apparently from a corpse midbattle and in which he had fought all day. He did not shed it now but ranged among the troops of Argos and the allies, the shield on his shoulder dark with blood and his eyes like snuffed tapers.
In defeat one learns who are friends to him, and by whom he is accounted friend. Past midnight Alcibiades’ attendant summoned my brother and me to his tent. Only those most intimate were incl
uded—his cousin Euryptolemus, Mantitheus, Antiochus the pilot, Diotimus, Adeimantus, Thrasybulus, and a dozen others. This was the singular honor of our lives, Lion’s and mine, nor did either stand uncognizant of it.
It was a most dolorous caucus. What wisdom could be culled from calamity was carved like a dry goose and shared out absent appetite.
Defeat tolled the knell for our commander’s alliance. Mantinea and Elis would be compelled again into the Spartan fold, as would Patrae, whose long walls would be torn down. Orchomenos could not be held; Epidauris and Sicyon would be squeezed tighter beneath the foe’s screw. The Spartans would exile or execute the last democrats and take as hostages children of all suspect families. At Argos the democracy would fall; it would only be a matter of time before she, too, toppled into the Spartan bag.
Alcibiades did not speak all evening, permitting Euryptolemus to articulate as his surrogate, as he often did, so in tune were the cousins with each other’s cast of mind. Euro urged his kinsman to depart for Athens at dawn. Word of defeat would fly home; he must stand present to endure it with honor and to shore up those who had stood at his side.
Alcibiades would not leave. He must remain to take up the dead. “The dam is down, cousin,” he accounted. “We will not hold the flood.”
None slept that night. Retrieval parties formed up before dawn. Mules and asses, even cavalry mounts, had been rigged with the pole sleds called “baker’s boards”; wagons of the commissariat had been recruited, augmented by sledges and litters; men carried cloaks and blankets upon which a body may be borne. The Spartans sent across their priests of Apollo to sanctify the field and formalize permission to us to take up our dead. They had already reclaimed their own.