After we ate, Dulcie returned to the studio, and Emma settled down on the couch beside me.
"Will you read this to me?" Emma held up The Moffats. "I want to know about Rufus M."
Like most of the things in the cottage, the book was old. The cover was faded, and the pages had a soft, pulpy feel. My grandmother had scrawled her name on the title page, followed by the date June 5, 1945. Under it, Dulcie had written her name and June 2, 1977. Mom added her name the next year. It looked as if another name had been scribbled there, but someone had erased it. All that remained were a few faint pencil marks, impossible to read.
By the time I finished the first chapter, Emma was fast asleep. I lay on my side next to her, tired from our long walk. A fly buzzed against the window screen. The lake lapped the shore. After resting for a while, I went to my room and put on my bathing suit. Leaving Emma to her nap, I ran down the steps to the lake.
Before I waded into the water, I stopped by the studio. Dulcie was sitting on a stool, staring at an unfinished painting, another canvas washed with blues and grays and green. "Where's Emma?" she asked.
"Asleep. Is it okay if I go for a swim?"
Dulcie hesitated. For a moment I was afraid she'd say no. Mom would have. "Promise to stay out of deep water, and be careful." She dipped her brush into blue paint. "Be back in a half-hour or so."
I leaned against the door for a moment and watched Dulcie go to work on the painting. She was soon absorbed in adding daubs of dark blues and blacks.
Completely forgotten, I slipped outside and walked down to the lake. The water was so clear, I could see my toes and the pebbles on the bottom as if I were looking through glass. Schools of silver minnows darted in and out of clumps of grass, turning this way and that in perfect unison, tickling my legs as they swam past.
I waded through knee-deep water, watching the minnows. Every now and then I glimpsed bigger fish—trout, maybe—but they disappeared before I got a good look at them. Seagulls dipped and circled overhead, and the pine forest behind me rang with the cries of crows. The trees made the air smell like Christmas.
I was enjoying myself until I saw Sissy at the end of our stretch of sandy beach. Unaware I was near, she bent over a pile of sand, patiently shaping it into a castle with turrets. I watched her for a few moments, glad Emma was safely at home.
When Sissy began to dig a moat, I splashed out of the water. "Well, well, where have you been?"
She looked up, startled. "What's it to you?"
"Nothing," I said. "It's not like I missed you or anything."
Sissy frowned, her eyes narrowed against the sun. "Where's Emma?"
"Taking a nap." I sat down, scooped up a handful of sand, and watched it trickle slowly through my fingers.
"It's boring to sleep." Sissy went on digging her moat as if it was a lot more interesting than I was. She was wearing the same faded bathing suit. One strap slipped off her shoulder, and she pulled it back in place.
"Emma was pretty tired." I scooped up another handful of sand. "We walked all the way to Webster's Cove and back this morning."
"Why did you go there?"
"Emma was looking for your house. She thought—"
Sissy shook her head. "I don't live in Webster's Cove."
"Where do you live, then?"
Sissy pointed in the opposite direction. "That way."
"The other day you pointed toward the Cove."
She smiled an odd little smile, more of a smirk, actually, and began to make a road to the castle with beach stones. She placed each one carefully. "Maybe I don't like unexpected company."
Maybe I don't, either, I thought. Especially when it's you. Out loud, I asked, "What's your last name?"
Sissy smoothed her castle's walls, stroking the sand with both hands as if it were a cat. I could see the little knobs of her spine under her skin and the sharp jut of her shoulder blades. She was definitely ignoring me—which annoyed me.
"Do you have any brothers or sisters?"
No answer.
"What's your father do?"
Still no answer.
"My dad's a math professor at the university. He—"
Sissy shrugged as if she didn't care what my father did.
I made a path with bits of broken shells and pebbles. "I'm just trying to be friendly."
"No, you're not. You're being nosy." Her face hidden by her hair, Sissy decorated her castle with bits of driftwood.
What could I say? She was right. I wasn't being friendly—I wanted to know more about her.
After a while, Sissy brushed her hair to the side and looked at me. "Emma says Dulcie's an artist. Is she good?"
I nodded. "She's getting ready for a show in Washington, D.C."
"Lucky her. I've never been there. "Sissy frowned and tossed a stone at a seagull. It missed, and the bird hopped a few feet farther away. "I've never been anywhere. Just here—boring Sycamore Lake, boring Webster's Cove, boring Maine."
"But Maine's beautiful. People come from all over to see the ocean and the boats and the lighthouses—"
"They must be really stupid." Sissy threw another stone, harder this time. She missed again, but the gull squawked and flew away. "I'd give anything to leave here and travel all over the world."
"Maybe when you grow up—"
"You know what? You're stupid, too."
I stared at her, but she was too busy building a little driftwood fence around her castle to look at me. "Why are you so mad all the time?" I asked her.
"What makes you think I'm mad?" She stuck a seagull's feather into the top of her castle and sat back to study the effect. "How about your mother? Is she an artist, too?"
"No."
"Why doesn't she like the lake?"
"Like Emma said, she's scared of water." I paused. Even though I didn't trust Sissy's sly eyes and mean mouth, she'd lived around here all her life. Maybe she'd heard people talk about the cottage. Unlike Erin, she wouldn't change the subject to spare my feelings.
Sissy stared at me, waiting for me to go on. Taking a deep breath, I said, "I think something happened the last summer Mom and Dulcie came to the cottage—something they don't want to talk about. Maybe something..." I hesitated and dropped my voice to a whisper. "Maybe something bad."
"You're right," she said. "Something bad happened, and lots of people know just what it was."
I drew in my breath and let it out slowly. "Do you know?"
Sissy tugged her bathing suit strap into place again and got to her feet. "That's for me to know and you to find out," she said with a smirk.
I jumped up and faced her. "You don't know anything, and neither does anyone else. You're making up stories, that's all."
"Think what you want. See if I care." Sissy turned her back on me and ran down the beach toward the Cove.
I watched her until I couldn't see her anymore. Brat. Did she really know something? Or was she lying? With one kick I demolished her castle and then splashed home through the water, sending the minnows racing for cover. The next time I saw her, I'd tell her to stay away from Emma and me.
Emma was perched on the boathouse steps, waiting for me. In the studio, Dulcie had Wagner turned up loud. I could see her through the door, painting another canvas with dark shades of purple and gray. A stormy day at the lake, I guessed.
"Where have you been?" Emma asked.
"For a walk."
"Did you see Sissy?"
I watched a gull land on one of the dock's pilings. "No," I lied.
"I wonder where she is." Emma gazed up and down the shore, as if hoping to spot Sissy.
"Oh, she'll turn up one of these days," I said, sure it was true. No matter how much I wished she'd go away, Sissy would keep coming back. She probably didn't have any other friends. Who'd want to play with someone like her?
"She'd better. Next to you, she's my best friend." Emma followed me up to the cottage, looking back every now and then, still hoping.
"Let's play a game," I said, thin
king I might get her mind off Sissy. "How about Candy Land?"
"Okay." Although she didn't sound very enthusiastic, Emma watched me pull the box down from a shelf stacked with checkers, dominoes, Chinese checkers, Clue, Parcheesi, Chutes and Ladders—everything you could possibly want to play.
I laid the board on the floor between us. While Emma picked out four green playing pieces, I noticed that Mom and Dulcie had written their names in two corners of the board. The handwriting was loopy and childish, and I imagined my mom with a crayon in her hand, laboriously printing "Claire."
"What's that say?" Emma pointed to the names.
"Dulcie and Claire. I guess this was their game."
"How about this?" Emma pointed at a scribbled-over place on the third corner. "What's it say?"
Under a dark smear of black crayon, I made out the letters T-e-r-e-s-a. "Teresa," I whispered. "It says Teresa."
I stared at the board. A little prickle as sharp as a razor raced up my spine and tickled my scalp. Teresa. T for Teresa. The girl torn from the photograph, the girl I dreamed about—was her name Teresa?
"Why did somebody scribble on her name?" Emma asked.
"I don't know," I said. But I'd find out.
"Maybe Mommy didn't like her," Emma said.
"Maybe not." Suddenly uneasy, I picked up the dice. It was weird how the cottage changed when evening shadows gathered in its corners. "Do you want to go first?"
We played three rounds, but it was hard for me to keep my mind on the silly game. My eyes returned again and again to Teresa's name. Who was she? Why was her name almost hidden by layers of black crayon? Why had she been ripped out of that photograph? I had to find out.
At the dinner table, Dulcie asked us what we'd done all afternoon. "We played Candy Land," Emma said. "I won two games, and Ali won one. She says I'm a champ." She held up her arms and flexed her muscles.
Dulcie laughed. "You've always been a champ."
Emma paused, her fork halfway to her mouth. "Who was Teresa, Mommy?"
"Teresa?" Dulcie stared at Emma, her body tense. "I don't know anyone named Teresa. Why?" She quickly got to her feet and began to gather the plates. The knives and forks rattled, the glasses clinked.
"She wrote her name on your Candy Land game." Emma followed Dulcie to the kitchen. "But somebody scribbled all over it with black crayon."
"I don't know what you're talking about." Dulcie scraped leftovers into the trash, her face hidden.
"I'll show you." Emma ran to the living room and came back with the Candy Land board. "See? Here's your name and Aunt Claire's name, and right there is Teresa's name."
Dulcie glanced at the board and shrugged. "Our mom used to buy stuff at church rummage sales. Some girl named Teresa probably owned the game before us, so we wrote our names and scribbled hers out."
It was a good explanation, but I didn't quite believe it. Something about that name upset Dulcie. She was tense, anxious.
"Remember that photo I told you about?" I asked her. "The one where the girl had been torn out? Well, her name started with T and I was wondering—"
"Will you please stop talking about it? How often do I have to tell you? I don't know Teresa, I don't know why her name is on that stupid game board, and I don't know who the girl in the picture was! She could have been named Tillie or Trudy or Toni."
Dulcie's sharp voice startled both Emma and me. I stared at my aunt, puzzled. Why was she so angry?
"Don't be mad, Mommy," Emma begged, close to tears.
"I'm not mad." Dulcie plunged her hands into the soapy water and began washing the dishes with swift, jerky movements. If she weren't careful, she'd break everything in the sink.
I grabbed a dish towel. "Want me to dry?"
Keeping her back turned, Dulcie shook her head. "I'd rather you read to Emma."
"But, Mommy," Emma began.
"Go with Ali," Dulcie said. "I need some time to myself."
Emma followed me into the living room and sat beside me, her small face glum.
I put my arm around her and drew her so close I could smell the sweet scent of her hair. "Would you like to hear another chapter about the Moffats?" I asked.
Emma nodded and snuggled against me. While I read, I thought about my aunt's reaction to Emma's questions. She remembered Teresa, I was sure she did. Why wouldn't she admit it?
9
The next morning, I slept late, probably because I'd tossed and turned most of the night, dreaming about Teresa. When I stumbled downstairs, eager for orange juice, I found Emma sitting at the kitchen table with Sissy. Turning her face so only I could see it, she smiled her smirky smile.
"Look who's here!" Emma cried, obviously delighted. "Sissy came to play with me!"
"Whoop-di-do," I muttered. "Where's Dulcie?"
"In her studio. She's got lots to do today, so we shouldn't bother her."
I took my seat at the table. Dulcie had already filled a bowl with my favorite cereal. As I added milk, I was aware of Sissy sitting beside me, close enough to touch. I wasn't in the mood to put up with her. Not after a bad night's sleep.
Ignoring me, Sissy busied herself pushing Cheerios around her bowl with her spoon, sinking them into the milk and watching them pop up again. As far as I could see, she hadn't eaten any of them.
I tapped her shoulder to get her attention. "It's bad manners to play with food." Even to myself, I sounded like a crabby old lady.
"So?" Sissy shrugged and continued to stir the cereal into a gloppy mess.
"So, if Dulcie was nice enough to fix cereal for you, you should eat it."
"Dulcie didn't give me this. Emma did. I told her I wasn't hungry, but she fixed it anyway."
I looked at Emma, and she nodded. "Mommy wasn't here when Sissy came, so I got to be the hostess."
"I hate cereal unless it's got lots of sugar on it." With a frown, Sissy pushed her bowl away. "Let's go to the lake, Emmy."
"I still have my jammies on."
"Get dressed, then, slowpoke." Sissy followed us into the living room and flopped on the couch. "I'll wait here."
Leaving Sissy looking at a magazine, I took Emma to her room and helped her out of her pajamas and into her favorite yellow bathing suit.
Emma ran to the living room to make sure Sissy was still there, and I dashed upstairs and yanked on my bathing suit. When I came down, Sissy was looking at the names written on the Candy Land board. The minute she saw me, she shoved it aside. The board fell off the table and onto the floor with a faint thud.
"Candy Land is a baby's game," Sissy told me. "I outgrew it a long time ago."
"Emma likes it," I said.
"No, I don't." Emma stood in the doorway, frowning as if I'd betrayed her. "I'm way too big to play it."
"You weren't too big last night," I reminded her.
"Well, today I am!" Emma flounced past me and smiled at Sissy. "Do you want to swim or build castles?"
"Both." Sissy let Emma take her hand. I followed the two of them outside.
At the top of the steps, Sissy looked back at me. "You aren't invited."
"Sorry, but Emma doesn't go anywhere without me," I said.
"I don't need you to baby-sit me," Emma protested. She was learning to scowl exactly like Sissy. The nasty expression didn't suit her sweet little face. Nor did the sly look she gave Sissy, hoping for her approval.
Sissy ran down the steps ahead of Emma and me and stopped at the bottom, almost as if she was afraid to go farther. "Is your mother in the studio?"
Emma nodded. "She's painting a big picture of the lake, all dark and scary, like a storm's coming." She reached for Sissy's hand. "Want to see it?"
"Dulcie'd love to meet you," I added.
Sissy took a quick look through the open door. Dulcie stood with her back to us, hard at work on another painting, darker than the first two. Lake View Three, she was calling this one.
"Hi, Mommy," Emma called. "We're going swimming!"
Sissy drew in her breath sharply an
d ducked away, as if she didn't want to be seen. Not that it mattered. Without turning around, Dulcie said, "Stay close to shore, Emma. Knee-deep, remember?"
Sissy ran to the end of the dock and posed in a diving position. Her tanned skin contrasted with her faded bathing suit and her pale hair. "Dare me?" she called to Emma.
"Not unless you swim really good," Emma said uncertainly.
"The water's over your head," I added.
"I'll do it, if you do it," Sissy said to Emma.
"No." I grabbed the straps of Emma's suit. "Emma can't swim."
"I can so!" Emma struggled to escape.
I held her tighter. "You're not allowed to jump off the dock unless your mother's here."
"Do you do everything Mommy says?" Sissy asked Emma. "Are you a little goody-goody girl?"
Emma looked confused.
"She has rules," I told Sissy, "like everyone."
"Not me," said Sissy. "I don't have any rules at all. I do whatever I want." With that, she jumped off the dock and hit the water with a big splash. She popped back up almost at once, laughing and spluttering. "Emma's a baby. She sucks her thumb and poops her pants and drinks from a bottle."
Emma began to cry. "I'm not a baby. I'm almost five years old. I can do whatever I want, too!"
With a sudden twist, Emma broke away from me and ran to the edge of the dock. Before I could stop her, she'd leapt into the lake. One second she was beside me, the next she was gone. I stared at the water in disbelief, too surprised to move.
In a few seconds, Emma's head emerged, eyes shut, mouth open, gasping for breath. Before she could sink again, I was in the lake beside her, holding her the way the lifeguard had taught me in swimming class.
Emma clung to me but turned her head to shout at Sissy, "See? I'm not a baby!"
Sissy paddled closer. Her hair floated on the water like pale yellow seaweed. "I bet you wouldn't jump if Ali wasn't here."
"I'll always be here," I told Sissy. To Emma I said, "If you do that again, I'll tell your mother."
"Tattletale, tattletale," Sissy taunted. "Nobody likes tattle-tales."