“Lucky for Harwood. Listen, you must come by the house some time.”
She forced a smile. “That’d be nice.”
“I know Trevor’s mother would be delighted to see you. How did you two meet?”
“Jesus, Dad,” Trevor said. “This really is turning into an investigation. Does Carol have the right to call her lawyer?”
Carol forced a laugh. “Trevor, it’s okay.”
Duckworth raised his hands as though admitting defeat. “None of my business anyway.”
He got up from the chair and gave his son one last nod. “See you later.”
“Yeah, sure,” Trevor said. “Can’t wait.”
Duckworth walked back to his car, got behind the wheel, and drove out of the Starbucks lot.
“God, I’m sorry about that,” Trevor said. “I don’t know what to say. I’ve never been so humiliated. He watched us.”
“It’s okay,” Carol said quietly. “He seems like a nice guy.”
Trevor said nothing.
“Do you think he could tell?” Carol asked.
“Think he could tell what?”
“That we both lied to him?”
Trevor considered that. “I hope not.”
FOURTEEN
IT was a long walk to Jessica Frommer’s house, but Brian Gaffney wasn’t troubled by that. Besides, it was closer than going back to his place and getting his car. He patted the front pocket of his jeans. At least he still had his keys. The bastard—or bastards—who’d done all this to him had stripped him of his wallet and his phone, but at least he’d be able to get into his apartment and start his car.
It sure was nice to get out of the hospital. Even though his family had come to see him, the visit had stressed him out. When his sister and mother started arguing, all he wanted was for them to leave. Once his mother left to find Monica and his dad, Brian decided he’d had enough. He wanted out of there before they returned to his room and started bickering all over again.
He felt badly for his father. It wasn’t his fault that Brian had decided to move out. He’d already been thinking about doing it. He’d landed this job at the detailing shop, and while it didn’t pay a fortune, it gave him enough money to rent a tiny apartment. It wasn’t like rents in Promise Falls were all that high. The town had lost so many jobs in the last few years—and a year ago, so many people—that a lot of rental units were going empty. On top of that, a lot of people had decided to leave, move away. The town had had such a run of bad luck that many feared it was never going to end. Best to get out before things got worse.
But even though Brian believed it had ultimately been his own decision to move out, his mother blamed his father for it. Albert had fully supported his son striking out on his own, learning to live independently. While Brian was no dummy, he was willing to concede he was no Steve Jobs or Mr. Spock or Sheldon Cooper—okay, those last two weren’t real, but still—and that sometimes people could get the better of him, confuse him.
Like this whole hepatitis thing. They were going to test to see whether he was positive for it. To Brian’s way of thinking, positive was good, so if he tested positive, that would mean he didn’t have it. But the doctor had explained to him that a good result would be a negative result, which would mean he did not have hepatitis.
Fuck, who knew. Why they couldn’t make things simpler, he didn’t know.
His dad had told him that if he ever had a question about anything, all he had to do was phone him. But he’d be okay out in the world, Albert assured him. He’d do fine.
And Brian was doing fine. Until he wasn’t.
The really good thing about being on his own, though, was privacy. Having your own place, you could come and go as you pleased. You could eat whatever you wanted. You didn’t have to explain yourself.
Maybe best of all was you could have a girl over.
A girl like Jessica Frommer.
Not that she’d ever actually stayed over at his place. But he’d believed that day was imminent. All the more reason to find her now and apologize. He was supposed to have met up with her during the time he was abducted. Since he no longer had a phone, he couldn’t call her, and without his wallet, he couldn’t even pay for a taxi.
So he would walk.
Brian figured Jessica would be surprised to see him. Not just because he hadn’t been in touch for a couple of days, but because she was unaware he knew where she lived.
One night they’d met up at the BestBet Inn, just off Route 98 on the road to Albany. Jessica never wanted to go anywhere with him in Promise Falls, and Brian wondered if that was because she thought maybe he wasn’t good enough for her, that she’d run into her friends when she was with him and be embarrassed. But she’d tell him she just thought Promise Falls was boring and it didn’t have any good restaurants. The BestBet, she said, had a pretty decent buffet. You could pick and choose what you wanted, and there was no limit on how much you could take.
Brian had started getting his hopes up that if Jessica wanted to meet him at a hotel, maybe she had plans that didn’t end with dinner.
He turned out to be right.
So after a meal that included pasta and roast beef and chicken wings and French fries and cherry pie with ice cream and about a dozen other things, Jessica confessed to him that she had booked them a room. At some point, around the time he was loading his plate with mashed potatoes, Brian must have lost hope that it was not going to happen. Now that he knew it was on, he was sorry he’d had quite so much to eat. He felt somewhat bloated.
But whatever.
They went upstairs and their first time was fast and clumsy. But within half an hour Brian was ready to go again, and things got so hot and heavy they didn’t notice that the winds outside were growing increasingly strong. Once Brian had finished, rolled off Jessica and collapsed onto his back on the bed next to her, they could hear the howling gale and the rain hitting the hotel room window. He pulled back the drapes to see a driving rain that was almost going sideways. Visibility was bad, and low spots in the road were flooding over.
Brian said they didn’t have to be in any rush. The room, after all, was booked until the morning. But Jessica said she had to get back home, no matter what the roads were like. Even though they’d brought two cars, Brian offered to give her a lift. He could bring her back the following day to pick up her vehicle. But Jessica said she’d driven through some of the worst snowstorms upstate New York had ever seen, so she wasn’t about to let a few puddles scare her.
Once Brian had helped her into her car, and watched her pull out of the BestBet parking lot, he ran to his own set of wheels, soaked to the skin, and took off after her. He stayed far enough back that she wouldn’t see him, and besides, all he was in her rear-view mirror at this time of night was a pair of headlights.
She was right. She was a good driver. She got back to her place on Pilgrim’s Way—a small one-story white house with black shutters—without incident. Brian drove right on by. He went to bed that night confident that Jessica was safely in hers.
Hey, it was just the kind of guy he was.
So, now that he was hoofing it, he knew where to go.
Along the way, he thought of all the other people he needed to get in touch with. He wondered if he still had his job at the car wash. He’d gone two days without showing up or making any calls to explain his absence.
They’d be pissed.
He figured he’d have to go to his parents’ house to use their phone to cancel his credit cards. Then there’d be the hassle of getting a new driver’s license. Man, hepatitis was the least of his worries.
He reached Pilgrim’s Way and strode down the sidewalk. It wasn’t dark yet, so the house was not hard to find. Jessica’s car, a blue compact four-door, was parked behind a Ford pickup.
Brian went up the steps to the door and rang the bell. He was thinking he’d have to show Jessica what had been done to his back, but he’d really have to work up to it. Didn’t want to freak her out.
r /> He could hear someone approaching the door. Quick, soft steps.
When the door opened, Brian had to look down. It was a girl, maybe four years old, in a pair of red pajamas. Curly blonde hair, rosy cheeks, bare feet. She looked up at Brian and grinned.
“Boo,” she said.
“Uh,” he said slowly, “I’m looking for Jessica?”
Could this be Jessica’s little sister? She hadn’t mentioned having one. If this girl was her sister, there sure was one hell of a big difference between their ages. More than twenty years, Brian figured. A visiting niece, maybe?
The little girl shouted, “Mommy!”
Brian felt a sudden queasiness in his stomach.
The child stayed by the door as Jessica shouted, “I’ll be right there, Gilda!”
The girl wiggled her nose as she looked up at Brian. “What’s your name?” she demanded.
Brian said, “Uh.”
Suddenly Jessica was there. Her expression was one of instant panic. “Go watch TV, Gilda.”
“There’s nothing on.”
“Go!” she said sharply.
Jessica did not invite Brian in. Instead, she closed the door partway and spoke to him through the crack. “What are you doing here? How did you find me?”
“I . . . I wanted to apologize. I was supposed to meet you and—”
“You have to leave. You have to leave right now.”
A man’s voice boomed from deeper inside the house. “Jessica!”
“Who’s that?” Brian asked, starting to feel overwhelmingly confused. “Is that your dad?”
“No, it is not my dad,” she whispered.
“Whose kid was that?” he asked. He was pretty sure he knew the answer, but he was hoping maybe, just maybe, he was wrong. Before she could answer, he said, “Aw, Jeez.”
“You have to go,” Jessica insisted.
“So you’ve got a kid?” Brian said. “And you’re married?”
“Please,” she said. “I was going to—I would have told you—”
“Ah man, I feel like such an idiot,” he said. “My family’s right. I really will fall for anyone’s bullshit. No wonder you didn’t want to be seen around here with me. I was starting to think maybe you were ashamed, but I get it now. You didn’t want to be—”
A hand came around the edge of the door and opened it wider. The hand, Brian quickly saw, was connected to a thin, ropy arm. Jessica’s husband was a good six feet tall, thin and wiry. His eyes were small and set deeply under his brow.
“What’s goin’ on?” he asked.
“Nothing,” Jessica said. “Just someone . . . What is it you’re selling again?”
Brian blinked. Thinking on his feet had never been an area in which he excelled. “Uh, I’m, uh . . .”
The man edged Jessica out of the way and came out onto the step. “Uh, what?”
“Ron, it’s nothing,” Jessica said to her husband. “He’s just going door to door. Is it a charity?” She looked at Brian with wide, hopeful eyes, trying to encourage him to play along.
But he wasn’t getting the message. “I just . . . I had an appointment with your wife and came by to explain why I wasn’t able to make it.”
“An appointment?” Ron cocked his head slightly to one side.
Brian nodded weakly. “You see, something happened to me. I was coming out of Knight’s, and—”
“You should go,” the man said.
“They did something to me,” Brian said, talking past Ron to Jessica, his voice starting to break. “They did something awful to me. I might even have hepatitis. I don’t know if I can die from that, but it could be bad. They’re doing tests.”
“Jesus, so you’ve got some sort of disease?” the man said. “Get the fuck out of here.”
“No,” Brian said, “it’s not something you can catch. At least, I don’t think so. Like I said, I . . . I was at Knight’s. And when I came out, someone—it might have been more than one person, I don’t know—but they grabbed me and—’
“You’re some sort of fucking lunatic,” Ron said. At which point he placed his palm solidly on Brian’s chest and gave him a shove.
Brian was pitched off the step. He hit the lawn on his back, which briefly knocked the wind out of him. He struggled to catch his breath as he got up on his knees. But before he could stand, Jessica’s husband put the toe of his boot into Brian’s chest. He screamed out in pain as he hit the ground.
Ron hovered over him. “You’re one of them, aren’t you? You’re one of the ones my wife’s been whoring around with.”
“I . . . I didn’t know,” Brian whispered.
“Just because she didn’t tell you doesn’t mean I won’t hold a grudge.”
And he kicked Brian a second time.
“You’ve gotten everything you got comin’ to you,” Ron Frommer said. “But that doesn’t mean there can’t be even more.” He turned and went back into the house.
Before the door closed, Brian, clutching his midsection, caught one last glimpse of Jessica’s fear-filled face.
FIFTEEN
BARRY Duckworth drove out of the Starbucks lot after meeting with his son and his girlfriend thinking: That could have gone better.
What a disaster. And yet, what was he supposed to do? Ignore the possibility that his son might be able to help him with a serious investigation? He had to talk to him on the off chance Trevor had seen something that would lead Duckworth to whoever had abducted and tattooed Brian Gaffney.
Still, maybe he could have done a better job of it. Maybe he should have talked to his son separately from this new girlfriend of his, Carol Beakman. Except she was a potential witness, too. He’d needed to talk to both of them.
And still . . .
He should have realized that once he’d told them he’d seen them on the Knight’s surveillance video, it meant that he’d seen them in an intimate moment.
Well, the hell with that, he thought. If he’d walked into Knight’s, he’d have seen the same damn thing. If you were going to stick your tongue down some girl’s throat while sitting in the middle of a bar, there was only so much privacy you could reasonably expect.
Maybe this would teach them to be a little more discreet, for crying out loud. Get a room.
Except, of course, Trevor’s room these days was in the Duckworth home.
He let out a long sigh.
Maybe he wouldn’t feel so conflicted about this if either of them had been able to tell him something useful. At least then the awkwardness would have been worth it. But as it turned out, neither Trevor nor Carol had seen a thing. They hadn’t even recognized Gaffney’s picture.
“Shit,” he said aloud.
But the more Duckworth thought about it, the more he wondered what the big deal was. Okay, he’d seen them making out. That was unfortunate. But did it justify Trevor’s hostility? Maybe he had a right to be annoyed, but why so instantly defensive?
Duckworth feared this was not the end of it. He wished now that Trevor hadn’t moved in with them. If his son still had his own place, Duckworth could avoid him almost indefinitely. But at some point today, Trevor would come home. That was not an encounter Duckworth looked forward to.
Which brought up the next dilemma. How much should he tell Maureen?
Forget all the investigative implications. At a purely personal level, Duckworth was now in possession of information that Maureen, who’d expressed concern about their son within the last hour, would definitely want to know.
Duckworth now knew Trevor was seeing someone. He knew her name. He even knew where she worked. Should he let Trevor fill his mother in at some point when he felt the time was right? And if he followed that course of action, what would Maureen do to him when she eventually found out he’d had this intel all along?
What a bloody mess.
He knew he’d tell Maureen. There were some things you couldn’t hold back. The trick would be trying to tell the story without making himself look like a total idiot in the
way he’d handled things.
If that was even possible.
“Shit,” he said again.
He kept replaying the scene at Starbucks in his head. I embarrassed him, he thought. Trevor had every right to be angry. The first time his father meets his girlfriend, he submits her to a police interrogation.
“I blew it. I totally blew it.”
What a terrific first impression. No wonder Trevor was pissed. Duckworth decided he’d have to apologize. Tell his son he was sorry for not handling things more tactfully.
You’re a cop for twenty-six years, and you still make mistakes.
God, he just wanted a donut. No, that wasn’t true. He wanted half a dozen donuts.
He had to put his problem with Trevor aside for now. Duckworth had something else to think about.
Craig Pierce.
Why had it taken him this long to think about Craig Pierce?
Okay, he had to cut himself a little slack. It had only been a few hours since Brian Gaffney had been brought into the police station. Only now were some of the similarities coming into focus.
Both Gaffney and Pierce had been sedated before horrible things were done to them.
In both cases, retribution appeared to play a major role. Craig Pierce was being punished for something he’d done, and it certainly appeared Gaffney was being made to pay for what had happened to “Sean,” whoever that turned out to be.
But there might come a time when Gaffney would actually consider himself lucky, at least compared to Craig Pierce.
Craig’s night to remember was 3rd February. Duckworth remembered the details of his statement.
Craig awoke to the sound of falling water. Torrents of it. An unrelenting rushing.
As he began to be more fully aware of his surroundings, he noticed how cold he felt. From the waist down, anyway. It was, after all, winter. (If Craig had anything at all to be grateful for, it was that this particular February was a mild one for upstate New York.)
His buttocks and the backs of his legs were particularly cold. That, he soon realized, was because they were resting on a thin layer of snow. He was outside, flat on his back, and all evidence pointed to the fact that he was half naked.