“Katie?”
I can tell by the soft paleness of her complexion that I roused her from sleep. A crease mark from her pillow mars her right cheek. She’s wearing a black dress and is in the process of tying her head covering as she steps into the hall. “I didn’t know you were here.”
“We need to talk,” I tell her.
Her expression goes wary. “Has something happened? If I’d known you were coming, I would have made coffee.”
“I don’t want coffee. What I want is for you to level with me.”
“About what?” Her eyes go into sharp focus on mine. “Have you found out something about the accident?”
“It wasn’t an accident, Mattie. Someone mowed them down. There’s a difference.”
“I know that, but…” Her voice trails and she looks down at the floor. “I don’t know what else to call it.”
“Try triple murder.”
She steps back, sets her hand on the jamb as if she needs the support to remain upright. “Why are you angry with me?”
I cross to her so that I’m less than a foot away. Her skin is as pale and flawless as a baby’s. Her eyes are deep and clear. She’s magnetic and, even as a female, I can understand why men are drawn to her. She smells of baby powder and laundry detergent and summer sun.
“Let me spell it out for you.” My voice feels like a steel zipper being ripped from my throat. “I asked you if you’d had any recent disagreements or arguments with anyone. It’s a straightforward question, Mattie. Then I hear about you and an unidentified man arguing on the road in front of your house in the middle of the night. What am I supposed to make of that?”
She chokes out a sound that’s part laugh, part incredulity. “I don’t know who you’ve been speaking with or what they said to you, but no such thing ever happened.”
In the years we’ve been friends, Mattie has shocked me, infuriated me, and made me laugh. The one thing she’s never done is lie. But I see the quicksilver flash of conscience in her eyes, and the truth of it hurts a hell of a lot more than I thought it would. “You’re keeping something from me. I suggest you start talking and, if it’s not too much trouble, focus on the truth.”
She takes a step back, presses her hand to her breast. I steel myself against the hurt in her eyes, remind myself that a man and two children are dead and I have a job to do.
“You’re being purposefully cruel,” she says quietly.
“I’m asking a question I want answered. Who was the man?”
“Katie, I am a Plain woman. I don’t speak with strange men in the—”
“There’s nothing Plain about you,” I cut in, and the words make me sound like a petty, jealous shrew.
She looks away as if the words shame her.
“I have a witness, Mattie. They saw you. They saw him. I know he’s Amish—”
“Sell is nix as baeffzes.” That is nothing but trifling talk. Looking shaken, she sputters the words in Pennsylvania Dutch.
“Is it?” I tilt my head and lean closer, invading her space, getting in her face. “Wu schmoke is, is aa feier.” Where there’s smoke there’s fire.
“Please stop.”
“Someone ran down that buggy and killed your husband and children. I’ve been beating my head against the wall trying to figure out who and why.” I slam the heel of my hand against the jamb next to her head. “And you’re playing games with me!”
“I’m not…” Her breaths come short and fast, as if she’s in the throes of a panic attack. “I would never…”
I don’t know if I’m right about any of this. The one thing I do know is that she’s keeping something from me, so I don’t give her a respite. I’m truly angry, but part of my display is calculated. I want her shaken. Even better if she’s furious with me. Because I know Mattie. Pressure is the only way I’m going to get anything out of her.
“I want the truth and I want it now!” I shout.
“Please. Leave me alone!” She lowers her head and puts her face in her hands. The cry that follows is so wrenching I feel the hairs on my arms prickle, the threat of tears at the backs of my own eyes. I shake off both.
I give her a moment to regain her composure, then ask, “Who is he?”
Her shoulders shake as she sobs uncontrollably into her hands. I wait, letting her hurt, resisting the urge to set my hand on her shoulder. All the while doubt and guilt poke a pointy finger at my back, laughing at me because I’m wrong about this. I’m wrong about her and I’ve destroyed one of my oldest friendships on a hunch I wasn’t sure about to begin with.
After a moment, she raises her gaze to mine. Her nose is red, her cheeks mottled and streaked with tears. “Please don’t tell,” she whispers. “Please, Katie, I couldn’t bear it if anyone knew.”
“Knew what?” I snap.
“Wayne Kuhns. He tried to … He wanted to…”
I know most of the Amish in and around Painters Mill, but that name isn’t familiar. “What did he do to you?”
“He didn’t do anything. But he … he wanted to … be with me. He tried to … you know, the way men do sometimes.”
Surprise is like the slash of claws across my face. I break a sweat beneath my uniform. I’m aware of my heart thrumming against my ribs. I stare, knowing I shouldn’t be shocked, but I am.
“Mattie, did he hurt you? Did he force you to do something you didn’t want to do?”
“No. I … pushed him away.”
“Did you have an affair with him?”
“No! Of course not. Katie, I’m married in the eyes of God. I would never forsake my vows. I wouldn’t do that to Paul or to myself.” Her mouth quivers. “I can’t believe you would think that about me. Now please, I just want to forget it ever happened.”
“Are you kidding me?” I choke out a laugh, incredulity ringing hard in my voice. “What were you arguing about?”
“He wanted to … be with me, and I told him it would never happen. He became upset and began shouting. It was upsetting and very uncomfortable.”
“Where was Paul?”
He was at his parents’ house up in Fredericktown. His mamm had just had a stroke.”
I nod, recalling that Paul’s mother recently passed. “What were you doing outside that time of night?”
“It wasn’t that late. Still light, in fact. I saw Wayne coming down the lane in his buggy.
“That’s not what I heard.”
“I don’t know where you’re getting your information, Katie, but I know exactly what time it was. I’d just put the children to bed.” Mattie cocks her head. “You’ve been talking to that Schlabach girl, haven’t you?”
“I’m not going to get into that with you.”
“I don’t want to speak ill of a child, especially a troubled child. But Sarah is known for telling tall tales.”
I say nothing.
“Sarah Schlabach makes up stories, just like her mamm used to. You remember how Martha was. She never liked me.” She looks down, presses her hand against her abdomen. “Sarah may have a sweet little face, but she’s a troubled child, Katie. In fact, she was mean to Norah once. They were playing and my sweet little girl came in with a black eye.”
That wasn’t my impression of the Schlabach girl, not even close, but I keep the thought to myself. The time discrepancy bothers me, but I can get to the bottom of that later. For now, I need to know about Wayne Kuhns.
“You need to tell me about Kuhns, Mattie. And I mean all of it. Right now.”
She looks down at her hands. “Let’s sit.” But I know she doesn’t want to risk the woman downstairs overhearing us.
I nod, and she takes me into her bedroom. Closing the door behind us, she motions toward a rocking chair at the window. She sits on the edge of the bed and puts her hands in her lap. “He started coming over about eight months ago.” She says the words so quietly I have to lean forward to hear. “At first it was innocent. The kind of thing a neighbor does. He would drop by on his way to the market and ask if we
needed anything. Sometimes he would bring squash or eggs or bread. Once he helped Paul dig some postholes.”
She stops speaking and takes a moment to gather herself. “After a while, I knew it wasn’t innocent.” Shame seems to emanate from her pores, like greasy, nervous sweat. “I could tell by the way he looked at me. Nothing I could put my finger on. But his eyes were too bold. I knew it wasn’t right. I knew he wasn’t coming over to just to be a good neighbor.”
“He was coming to see you.”
“I think he was lonely and sad. I think he was having problems in his life. His faith.”
I stare at her, wondering how she could be so naïve. “Did you tell Paul?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
“I didn’t want to upset him or turn it into some big issue. I know it may not make sense to you, Katie, but you’re not Amish anymore. You’re not married.” She struggles to find the right words. “I felt … ashamed. I mean, I know it wasn’t my fault; I hadn’t done anything wrong. But still … I know this sounds dense, but I didn’t want to get Wayne into trouble. His wife had just found out she was expecting. I thought it was a passing thing.”
I stare at her, sensing I’m not getting the full story. She’s leaving something out, so I push. “What aren’t you telling me?”
She picks at a hangnail that’s already picked down to the quick. “You know how the Amish are. Sometimes they talk.”
“You mean about you?”
“About the way I look. Some of the women … they don’t like me. Sometimes they’re all too willing to lay blame where there is none.”
“So you didn’t mention it to Paul or anyone else because you thought the women would gossip about you? Blame you?”
“Come on, Katie. You know how they are. Look at how they treated you.” Grimacing as if the memory of my leaving still pains her, she lowers her head, rubs at her forehead with her fingertips. “The women would think I’d somehow tempted him. That it was my fault.”
“Tell me the rest of it.”
“Things got bad when Wayne started coming over when Paul wasn’t home. That was when I knew the problem wasn’t going to go away on its own.”
“Did he ever touch you inappropriately, Mattie? Did he ever try to do something you didn’t want him to do?”
Before she looks away, I see misery and shame in the depths of her eyes and, despite everything, I’m moved. I want to put my arms around her and tell her everything’s going to be all right. That she didn’t do anything wrong. But I don’t.
“He tried to, you know, kiss me. Once. He’d brought eggs and we were in the kitchen. He just sort of tried to put his mouth on mine. You know, all awkward-like, and I pushed him away.”
“Did he get the message?”
She averts her eyes again. “That last night, the night Sarah told you about, I threatened to go to his wife and tell her what he was doing. He stopped coming after that.”
“You never told Paul?”
“No.” Fresh tears pour from her eyes, but she makes no move to wipe them away. “Now I feel as if I betrayed him. As if I’ve done something wrong. I know I didn’t, but he’s gone and I’ll never have the chance to make it right.”
I look away. Even though the door is closed, I can hear the clanging of pots and pans being washed and dried in the kitchen. “How did Kuhns take it when you threatened to go to his wife?”
“He was angry. I mean, at first. But he is Amish, Katie. Aside from his weakness for the women, he’s a good man. He knew what he was doing was wrong. He loves his wife. In the end, he agreed to stay away.”
“Did he ever lose his temper or threaten you in any way?”
“Oh, no, Katie. He knew it was the devil’s thoughts running through his mind. He fought them and in the end he won.”
“Is he a jealous man? Did he ever show any anger toward you or Paul?”
“Never.”
“When’s the last time you had contact with Kuhns?”
“That night on the road six months ago. I’ve prayed for him every day since.”
“Has he tried to contact you?”
“No.”
“Did he ever stalk you?”
“No,” she says.
“Have you seen him at all? Or run into him anywhere? Even by accident?”
“I see him at worship on occasion. He never even looks my way.”
“What about in town? Or when you’re out running errands?”
“No.”
“Have you seen him hanging around the farm?”
“Never.”
I stare hard at her. “Is there anything else you want to tell me about Kuhns? Is there anything you left out?”
“He didn’t do this thing, Katie. He would never hurt Paul or the children. He is a husband and soon to be a father. More importantly, he is Amish. He wouldn’t hurt a fly. Of that, I’m certain.”
As I rise and make my way to the door, all I can think is that she has a hell of a lot more faith in human nature than I do.
* * *
When you’re Amish—even formerly Amish, like me—some things are so ingrained you can’t escape them. Harsh judgment is one of them. I haven’t been Amish for almost eighteen years—more than half of my life—but as I turn onto the highway I feel all of those tattered morals rising to the surface. I don’t consider myself a religious woman. I don’t attend church or pray before meals. But I do believe in fidelity.
I’m well aware that the Amish are held to higher moral standards than their English counterparts. Because of their strict belief system, they have farther to fall from that perch of righteousness. It’s hypocritical of me to stand in judgment of another soul. My own résumé isn’t exactly squeaky clean, and you sure don’t have to dig too deep to find dirt. I’m a sinner just like everyone else. Perhaps more so because of the nature of my crimes. But old habits die hard.
I find myself chomping at the bit to speak with Wayne Kuhns. Finally, I have a possible motive. It wouldn’t be the first time a stalker had acted on some dark impulse. One of the first objectives of the stalker is to isolate his victim. Eliminate their support system in the hope they will turn to him. In Mattie’s case, he would have also eliminated his competition: her husband.
I call Lois on my way to the station and ask her to run Wayne Kuhns through LEADS. I’m not surprised when he comes back clean. But even seemingly decent, God-loving people can have a hidden dark side, especially when it comes to lust.
Normally, when dealing with the Amish, I prefer to do it alone, for the simple reason that they’re more apt to speak openly to me, if only because of my background. But because of my past friendship with Mattie, I want an objective opinion, so I swing by the station and pick up Glock. I give him the details of my conversation with Mattie on the way to Kuhns’s house.
“You think Kuhns was stalking her?” he asks.
“I thought we might ask him.”
“Damn.” He whistles. “The kids. That’s cold blooded.”
“Wouldn’t be the first time some obsessive narcissist took out his competition.”
“Takes a sick son of a bitch to do something like that.” He motions right. “There’s the street.”
I make a hard right and park at the curb in front of a nondescript frame house with white siding and small concrete porch in the front. From where I’m sitting, I see a one-car detached garage off the alley. The overhead door stands open and yellow lantern light spills into the backyard.
Most Amish in the area live on farms. But with a limited amount of land, and the cost of owning it increasing, some have adapted their lifestyle to keep up with the times. Glock and I take the sidewalk to the front porch. The sound of hammering draws my attention and I realize someone is in the garage off the alley. Instead of going to the front door, we take the sidewalk around the side of the house toward the rear. An old chain-link fence stops us, but there’s no dog in sight, so I open the gate and we continue toward the garage.
I’m a few yards from the door when the sound of sawing reaches me. Through the window, I see Kuhns hunched over whatever project he’s working on. The smells of sawdust and kerosene greet me when I enter. The shop is organized and well lit. A lantern burns from atop the workbench behind him. A second lantern hangs from an exposed beam overhead. Kuhns glances up from his sawing, but takes the time to finish his cut. He’s wearing typical Amish garb: gray trousers with suspenders, a blue work shirt, and a straw hat. I guess him to be in his midthirties. Physically fit. Attractive.
He doesn’t look surprised to see us as he straightens and sets the saw on the workbench. He’s building a doghouse, I realize. A nice one with stained trim, faux shutters, and a roof that opens for easy cleaning. Indoor/outdoor carpet lines the interior.
“Looks like that’s going to be a nice doghouse,” I begin.
He glances at his creation and I see a quick flash of pride in his eyes. “It’s a custom order for one of Mrs. Steinkruger’s customers.”
“Are you Wayne Kuhns?” I ask.
“Yes.” His eyes sweep to Glock and back to me. “What’s this about?”
I show him my badge and identify myself, then we shake hands. Glock hangs back, unobtrusive, but I know he’s watching the other man closely.
“I’m working on the Borntrager case,” I tell him. “If you have a few minutes, I’d like to ask you some questions.”
He physically recoils when I mention the Borntragers, and I know instantly that while Wayne Kuhns is either a wannabe adulterer or a stalker, he’s not proud of it, and he’s not very good at hiding his emotions.
“Did you know Paul?” I ask.
He nods. “I met him several times. At worship. The horse auction. Helped him a few times at the farm.”
“What about Mattie?”
He looks down at the floor. I give him a moment, but he doesn’t answer. I’m aware of Glock moving around, looking at the workbench, peering into the trash container.
“Mr. Kuhns?” I say.
“I know Mattie.”
“How do you know her?”
No reply. I don’t know if he doesn’t want to answer or if he’s so upset he can’t.
“How do you know Mattie, Mr. Kuhns?”