Page 42
It would seem longer once he was doing it, I thought. And if it still didnt seem long enough, he could always reenlist.
* * *
Some forty-five minutes out of Cleveland Havemeyer took a Valium, which was evidently his custom on long train trips. He offered me one but I passed. I would have liked one, but then I would have liked a pint of Early Times, as far as that goes. Havemeyer swallowed his Valium and put his seat back and closed his eyes, and that was the last I heard from him for the next five or six hours.
Id picked up a paperback at Newark before they called my flight, and Id never even opened it en route to Cleveland. I got it from my bag now and read for a while, pausing now and then to put the book down on my lap and look off into the distance, thinking long thoughts. Train travel lends itself to that sort of thing.
Sometime before dawn I closed my eyes, and when I opened them it was light outside and we were pulling into Rochester. I slipped off to the diner for a cup of coffee. Havemeyer was still sleeping when I got back.
He woke up not long after that and we got some breakfast and returned to our seats. He stayed awake the rest of the way but still seemed faintly tranquilized, not talking much. He read the Amtrak magazine, and when hed exhausted its possibilities I gave him the paperback Id given up on.
Around noon, shortly after we left Albany, I made a phone call. You could do that, they had a phone you could use, just running your credit card through a slot. I called the Sixth Precinct and managed to get Harris Conley. I told him I was on my way back from Cleveland with a suspect in the killing of Byron Leopold. I didnt even have to remind him who Byron Leopold was, but then its a name that sticks in your mind.
He said, "What did you do, arrest him? Im not sure of the legal status of that. "
"Hes with me voluntarily," I said. "Ive got a full confession on tape. Im not sure of the legal status of that, either, but Ive got it, along with the gun he used. "
"Thats pretty amazing," he said. He offered to have the train met by a contingent of cops, but I didnt think that was necessary. Havemeyer was coming in voluntarily, and I thought hed be more comfortable surrendering at the precinct. Besides, Id promised to keep him out of handcuffs as long as possible.
I wanted to second-guess myself when we got to Grand Central. There was a light rain falling and it had the usual effect of making the taxis disappear. But before too long one pulled up to discharge a passenger and we grabbed it and headed downtown.
* * *
I didnt have to stick around too long at the Sixth. I turned over the gun (which, unwrapped, turned out to be a. 38 revolver, with live rounds in three of its six chambers) to Conley, along with the tape of Havemeyers confession. I answered a battery of questions, then dictated a statement.
"Im glad I was around when you called," Conley told me, "and lucky I even remembered what you were talking about. I dont suppose I have to tell you we werent exactly pushing this one. "
"Thats no surprise. "
"Triage," he said. "You put in your time on the ones you stand a chance of breaking. And the ones where theres a lot of heat from up top. "
"Thats how its always been. "
"And always will be, would be my guess. Point is, this wasnt a front-burner case, not after the first seventy-two hours. And the whole citys so nuts today, especially the department, its a wonder I remember my own name, let alone yours and Byron Leopolds. "
"Why is the city so nuts?"
"You dont know? Where the hell did you spend the past twelve hours?"
"On a train. "
"Oh, right. But even so, didnt you see a newspaper? Listen to the radio? You came through Grand Central, you must have walked past a newsstand. "
"I had luggage to carry and a confessed murderer to escort," I reminded him. "I didnt have time to care what was happening in Bosnia. "
"Forget Bosnia. Bosnia didnt make the headlines today. It was all Will this morning. "
"Will?"
He nodded. "Either its Number One back from the dead or Number Twos more dangerous than anybody thought. You know the theater critic?"
"Regis Kilbourne. "
"Thats the one," he said. "Will got him last night. "
24
You could almost say hed been asking for it.
Id somehow missed the column he wrote. It had appeared toward the end of the previous week, not in the Arts section where his reviews always ran, but on the Timess oped page. Ive since had a look at that issue of the paper, and it seems to me I read Safires column that day, an inside-the-mind-of piece on a pair of presidential hopefuls. So I very likely took a look at what Regis Kilbourne had to say, and probably stopped reading before I got to the payoff.
That would have been natural enough, because his brief essay started off as a spirited defense of freedom of the press. Hed said the same things before, in response to having been given a spot on Wills list, going on about a critics profound responsibilities to his conscience and his public. I might very well have decided I didnt have to listen to all that again.
Hed used up the greater portion of his 850 words before he got to the point. The rest of his column was given over to a review of a dramatic production, but this particular show was staged neither on nor off Broadway but all over town. He reviewed Will, and he gave him a bad notice.
"It is customary but by no means imperative," he wrote, "to revisit a long-running show after a substantive change in the cast. When the original production was essentially a star vehicle, such revisits are almost always disappointing. And this is certainly true in the case of what, were it mounted as a Broadway musical, some producer would surely entitle Will! complete down to the nowobligatory exclamation point.
"In its first incarnation, Will! was unquestionably good theater. With the late Adrian Whitfield quietly elegant in the title role, the production had a powerful grip on its audience of eight million New Yorkers. But what succeeded initially as brilliant tragedy (albeit not unleavened by its comic moments) has come back to us as farce, and a farce with all the zest and sparkle of a fallen souffl?.
"With Whitfields death and unmasking, his understudy has emerged from the wings-and has fallen flat on his face. Will Number Two, as we seem to be calling him, is a man of bombast and empty rage. We take this pale copy seriously only because we remember the original.
"No more. Youre only a pack of cards, Alice said, scattering her adversaries to the four corners of Wonderland. I say the same to this craven who drapes himself in the fallen Whitfields garb. No longer will I go about guarded and live as if under siege. No longer will one seat of my two on the aisle be taken up by a burly chap whod much rather be home watching NYPD Blue. Im taking my life back, and I can only recommend the same course of action to the current Will. Close the show, strike the set-and get a life. "
* * *
Kilbourne had made his decision on his own, but hed let the cops know about it before his oped piece informed the rest of the world. While theyd advised against it, nobody tried very hard to talk him out of it. Theyd reached much the same conclusion he had. Copycat killers can be as dangerous as the original, but it was beginning to look as though Will wasnt a copycat killer after all. He was a copycat letter writer. He would still be pursued, and eventually caught, but there was a lot less urgency attached to the matter.
So Tuesday night, while I was playing hearts with a college student and a confessed murderer in the kitchen of a ranch house in Lakewood, Ohio, Regis Kilbourne was watching a preview performance of the new P. J. Barry play, Poor Little Rhode Island. His companion was a young woman named Melba Rogin, who looked like a model but was in fact a fashion photographer. After the performance the two had drinks and a light supper at Joe Aliens, then took a taxi to the brownstone in Chelsea where he had a floor-through apartment on the parlor floor.
At 1:15 or thereabouts he suggested she stay over, but she had an early shoot and wanted to get home. (One of the tabloids had her specul
ating on what would have happened if shed stayed the night. Would Kilbourne still be alive? Or would she have died along with him?) He walked to Seventh Avenue with her and put her in a cab headed downtown-her loft was on Crosby Street-and the last she saw of him he was on his way home.
He evidently went straight back to his apartment, and sometime within the next hour or two he had a visitor. It appeared that either Will had managed to get hold of a key or Kilbourne let him in, as there were no signs of forced entry. Nor did Kilbourne seem to have resisted his killer. Hed been struck on the head with some heavy object, the blow delivered with enough force to have very likely rendered him unconscious. Hed either fallen to the floor or been laid out there, facedown. Then the killer stabbed him in the back with a Sabatier carbon-steel kitchen knife, which had been subsequently removed from the corpse, washed in the sink, and placed in the wire basket to dry.
("Wills probably not a chef," Elaine told me. "You have to hand-dry knives like that. Theyre not stainless, and theyll rust. A chef would have known that. " Maybe he knew, I said, and didnt care. A chef would have cared, she said. )
I dont know that the knife had time to rust, but I do know there were traces of blood still on it, which nailed it down as the murder weapon. There were no prints on it, though, or prints other than Kilbournes and Melba Rogins anywhere in the apartment.
Kilbourne was found fully dressed, wearing the slacks and sweater hed donned to put Melba in a cab. (She said hed worn a brown suede baseball jacket as well, and that garment had been found slung over the back of a chair. ) Either Will had arrived before his victim had gone to bed, or Kilbourne had dressed again in the same clothes before answering the door. According to Melba, hed been wide awake when she left him, so he might have stayed up to read or watch television, or even to write his review.
If hed done any writing, hed left no sign of it. He still used a typewriter, an ancient Royal portable that evidently had some sort of totemic status in his eyes. There was no work-in-progress in his typewriter, no notes alongside it. Some reporter asked Melba Rogin how hed liked the play-hed probably have asked the same question of Mary Lincoln-and she claimed not to know. According to her, he would never say anything about a play until hed written his review. "But I dont think he loved it," she admitted.
That opened up a new vein of speculation. Some wit got his name in Liz Smiths column by theorizing that Kilbourne had hated the play and written a withering review, and that his late-night visitor was the playwright himself, P. J. Barry, whod struck down his tormentor before taking home the offending review and consigning it to the flames. "But I know P. J. Barry," Smith wrote, "and Ive seen Poor Little Rhode Island, and I can no more imagine P. J. doing such a thing than I can believe anyone could find a bad word to say about his play. "
There were no calls to or from Kilbournes apartment around the time the murder would have occurred, no reports of strangers entering or lurking around the brownstone. Sooner or later, though, they would turn up a witness, someone whod seen someone coming or going, someone whod heard a shout or a cry, someone who knew something.