He shrugged. “I like bad ideas.”
Holding his gaze, I said, “We have that in common.”
His head dipped, readying to kiss me again when a voice called out from several feet away. “Wyatt Shaw, what are you doing to that poor girl this early in the morning?”
Instead of his lips, his forehead dropped to mine and his eyes slammed shut. I watched with no small amount of fascination as his entire face turned red.
“Hey, Jo,” he called back.
Aw crap.
Finally, he pulled away, exposing me to the most terrifying woman in all of creation. “Kaya, is that you?”
“H-hi,” I croaked. “Hi, Jo.”
She shook her head, apparently disappointed in both of us. I felt thirteen again, when I’d been caught making out with Danny Brayburn in the fellowship hall of our church by Mrs. Minch, the seventy-year-old organ player.
Jo snorted. “Did you only come out here to make a spectacle of yourselves? Or are you going to buy some produce?”
“That one,” Wyatt said, clearing his throat and fidgeting. “The, uh, second one. I’d planned on saving the spectacle for after.”
It was my turn to turn the color of a ripe strawberry. Jo let out a shocked cackle. “Then let’s get this over with so you can get back to it.”
Jo turned and marched off to her stand while I tried to catch the shriveling pieces of my dignity. Wyatt turned back and grinned at me. “You heard her, let’s get this over with so we can get back to it.”
He grabbed my hand and pulled me after him. “Not happening,” I hissed at his back. “That was the last time.”
“You keep saying that,” he said without looking at me. “You’re like the boy who cried wolf. I don’t believe you anymore.”
We came to a stop in front of some of the lushest produce I’d ever seen. Shiny, oddly shaped heirloom tomatoes and long, bumpy cucumbers. Perfectly round radishes. Juicy strawberries. Jars of orange marmalade and raspberry preserves. We were standing in front of a carefully guarded gold mine. My spirits instantly lifted.
“You’re going to be disappointed then,” I told Wyatt as my fingers itched to grab for the beauties laid out in front of me.
He leaned in, his breath a whispery tickle over the shell of my ear. “Your denial is cute. But we both know you’ve got it bad for me, Swift. So, so bad.”
Chapter Fifteen
I had a flat of produce that I had no idea what I was going to do with or when I was going to use it, seeing as I worked every single night. But I couldn’t help myself. Jo had the best of the best. Her stand was a chef’s dream.
And fortunately for us, she worked with Ezra’s restaurants almost exclusively. Wyatt had wandered off to check something out for Jo in her truck. Apparently, he was a bit of a mechanic too. That shouldn’t have been another turn on, but damn it, picturing him all greasy and shirtless and under a car was pretty much the hottest thing I’d ever imagined.
Everything Wyatt did was suddenly hot. I mean everything. He could have flossed his teeth and I would have worried about my panties melting off my body. It was obnoxious.
Jo eyed me across a pile of figs. “I haven’t seen Wyatt with a girl in a long time. Not since the last one that hated food. Could have told you she wasn’t going to work out. Personal trainer my ass. She wouldn’t eat his food. That was a big enough sign that astronauts could see it from space.” She pursed her lips and added, “Not that I don’t think there have been other girls. He doesn’t bring them around me anymore. He doesn’t like my opinions.”
I didn’t know if that was an insult or a commentary on factual history. Steeling my nerves, I told my courage to cowboy up. I was tougher than Jo wanted to believe I was.
“We’re not really here together,” I told her evenly. “You caught us at a weird time.”
She raised an eyebrow. “You’re in the habit of kissing boys you’re not with?”
Well, shit. I searched for my usually sharp temper, but I couldn’t seem to find it today. Instead, something else came out of my mouth. Something stupid and kind of pathetic. “How many girls do you think there are?”
Her lips twitched like she wanted to smile, but she held it back, reminding me so much of Wyatt in that moment that my chest pinched. “I thought you said you’re not with him. What does it matter to you?”
I glanced at the sky, hoping help would fall from it. “Because I’m really not in the habit of kissing boys I’m not with,” I confessed. “And…”
“And it’s Wyatt,” she finished for me, sounding as confused and unsure as I did. “I’ll tell you this much, Wyatt has never brought a girl to this stand. Not even one he casually works with. So, you two could have stepped up here as businesslike as you please and I would have known something was up immediately. But you didn’t step up here. I think you circled the damn place fifteen times before I caught you smooching. So, all that to say, there aren’t other girls, honey. There’s you.”
My heart kicked in my chest, harder and faster than a freaking kangaroo on the offensive. “I thought he hated me.”
“I’ve known Wyatt a long time. I can honestly say I’ve never known him to hate anyone.”
She didn’t know us before the constant making out… “Any words of advice?”
She smiled this time and the expression softened her face, making her look years younger and possibly approachable. “Don’t hurt him.”
I took it back. She wasn’t approachable. She was a grinning viper. Her mouth stretched wide, readying her for her attack. Yikes!
Licking dry lips, I tried to form the right response. “I’m not planning to,” came out instead.
“Don’t worry about planning,” she snapped back. “Don’t do it. That boy doesn’t trust people. And I mean, not at all. His mama was about as awful as they come, and she messed him up real good. Don’t be another woman that disappoints him. Don’t give him another reason to stay alone.”
Shit. And holy shit. What was I even supposed to say to that? I couldn’t promise her those things! I didn’t know what was going to happen with Wyatt and me, but happily ever after was a ridiculous stretch of the imagination. More than likely I would disappoint him. Probably even today. Hell, I felt like I had already disappointed him as his employee about one hundred times in the last six months. Don’t give him another reason to stay alone? I was like the definition of why men should stay alone. Run. Hide your men. The she-wolf is on the prowl!
Good grief, Jo had messed with my head in about the most severe way possible. And now she was looking at me, waiting for a response. All I wanted to do was throw my hands in the air and run away screaming.
“We’re just…” Friends? No, that wasn’t the right word.
Enemies? Wrong too. Especially now.
Competition? That felt more like reality, but how could I explain that to Jo in a way that would make the kissing make sense?
“We’re uh…” I tried again.
“Yeah, yeah,” she waved me off. “I know what you’re doing. And I also know that two of his brothers have recently settled down and it’s started a fire in that boy that he didn’t know needed to be kindled. Now he’s out looking for that girl, the one that’s going to save him from himself.” Her eyes narrowed, becoming shrewder, less trusting—if that was even possible. “My guess is he thinks that girl is you, Miss Swift. I’m asking that if you’re not also looking for someone serious, that you let him down before he’s too invested, to give him a chance to recover.”
I pressed a fist to my stomach and leaned forward, desperate to catch my breath. “Damn, you’ve put a lot of pressure on me.”
She cackled again, sounding more and more like an evil witch from a Disney cartoon movie. “It’s only fair to warn you, I love that boy like my own. I want to see him happy.” She leaned forward on her hands, bringing her head closer to mine. “But mostly, I don’t want to see him hurt. I think we have that in common.”
She was right. I didn’t want to hurt him.
No matter what my feelings were for him. And to be honest, I was still trying to sort through them and give them names. They ping-ponged back and forth frantically between my head and my chest, never landing long enough for me to pin one down.
My head argued that we had a cruel and competitive past together and that absolutely nothing could come out of an attempted relationship between us except more cruelty and a hell of a lot more competition.
But my heart spoke in a language that didn’t involve words. It beat with the hope of something my brain couldn’t yet describe. And it raced with anticipation for more of the kissing. More touching. More talking. More smiling. More everything.
They didn’t agree, my head and my heart. And the feeling of my body being in such staunch disagreement made my stomach flip in protest.
Damn, Kaya, get it under control.
“You’re right,” I told Jo. “I care enough about him to not want to see him hurt. I’ll be careful with him.”
She lifted a hand, pointing a stern finger at me. “I didn’t say anything about being careful. My Wyatt wouldn’t know the first thing about being careful. I’m asking you not to screw this up. He’s trying, girl. He’s brought you to this place that is sacred for him, for all his brothers. He’s trusted you in ways I don’t believe he’s trusted anyone since his mama died. Don’t be careful with him. Just don’t fuck this up.”
“Yes, ma’am.” My response was immediate and triggered by the sharp tone of her voice. My eyes bugged at her curse word, surprised to hear it come from someone who looked, even if she didn’t act, like a grandmother.
Her mouth broke into a satisfied smile. “That’s what I like to hear.”
“Jo, I can’t find anything wrong with that truck other than it’s a hundred years old,” Wyatt exclaimed as he rounded the corner, wiping his hands on his pants. “You’re going to have to take it to the mechanic if it keeps acting up on you.”
“Oh,” Jo answered. “I’ll figure it out.”
She turned around to reach for a crate of fingerling potatoes in every shape and color and I had just enough time to glare at her back. Evil woman. There wasn’t anything wrong with her truck. She wanted to get rid of Wyatt for a few minutes, so she could lecture me!
Her lecture wasn’t going to work. Wyatt could take care of himself. He didn’t need scary mama Jo fighting his battles for him.
“Hey,” he said to me, standing close, popping my personal bubble with his height and body heat and irresistibility. “Sorry about that.”
My Wyatt, she’d called him. Only he wasn’t. He wasn’t hers.
I struggled to swallow and slow the rapid beating of my heart. But was he mine? “Hey.”
“I’m going to grab a few things from Jo and then I’ll be ready to go.”
Picking up my cardboard flat of odds and ends, I distanced myself from him. “Go for it,” I said quickly. “I should be going anyway. I need to drop all this off at home and change before work.”
His bright expression dimmed. “Are you sure? I’ll only be a second.”
“It’s fine. You’re fine.” I cleared my throat to get my mouth to stop saying dumb things. “I just don’t want to be late. My boss can be a real pain in the ass.”
His mouth kicked up in a half smile. “Yeah? Maybe I should say something to him.”
“Make sure he knows you mean business.” The fluttery, nervous beast inside me relaxed at our easy banter. This was more comfortable territory. This was familiar ground.
Jo had messed with my head with all her talk about fragile, committed, and damaged Wyatt. I needed to disentangle myself from her delusion and remember that I knew Wyatt, and we were only having fun. Or something like that.
It was impossible to date around with our hours. And the pressure and stress of our job kept us isolated, clinging to things we knew and didn’t have to try very hard for. That’s what I was to Wyatt. And that’s what he was to me. End of story.
He walked me to the dirt path that wound between vendors out to the parking lot. “Hey, I know your parents are coming this weekend. You should bring them by the restaurant.”
I smiled. As if. There were a lot of perks to working at Lilou. Not only prestige and industry-wide respect, but excellent food and access to one of the best kitchens in the region. However, just because I worked there didn’t mean I got to drop in whenever I wanted. In fact, employees were only allowed to make reservations once a year. The waitlist was so demanding, Ezra didn’t want his employees taking up tables. And when we were able to get our names down, we had to wait in line like everybody else.
“Are you going to set up a table in the alley? Feed us Lady and the Tramp style? Because my parents might enjoy it, but hello, awkward party of one.” I pointed to myself, shuddering at the image of my parents making out with a plate of spaghetti between them.
Gross. And no thank you.
He laughed at my joke, his eyes lighter and happier than I had ever seen them before. But again, this perspective of him was skewed. I was used to him yelling at me all the time, hating me. Our new… friendship? Or whatever you wanted to call it was seriously messing with my head. And my sex drive.
“Have they ever been?”
It took me longer than it should have to catch up in the conversation. I was lost in that look in his eyes, the one that made them so decadently brown, like rare, smooth whiskey. “To Lilou? No, they haven’t. Their style is more, um, how do I put this gently… Cracker Barrel.”
His smile stretched and warmed all at once. “I’ll get you a table then. For Saturday night? You can show them what you do. Impress them.”
“Are you serious?”
“Yeah. I bet they’d love to see where you work. And even though you won’t be cooking, they’ll get the idea.”
“Wyatt, I don’t know what to say. That’s unbelievably nice of you.”
He leaned forward, his grin turning wicked. “I’m trying to unseat your sister. No offense to her, but I can’t have anyone thinking someone else is better than one of my chefs.”
It was my turn to laugh, the sound bubbling out of me from the bottom of my toes, all the way through my chest, filling my lungs and giving me a fizzy feeling low in my belly. “I appreciate that.”
“You’re welcome.”
“Okay. Bye, Wyatt.”
“Bye, Kaya.”
I carried my produce back to my Land Cruiser and loaded the flat into the back seat. The doors screamed in protest as I opened and shut them, first for the veggies, and then for me. I ducked behind my steering wheel, feeling like the entire market was staring at me.
They weren’t. Nobody cared that my beautiful, vintage beater was noisy as hell. They went on with their business none the wiser that I’d shut myself in my car as quickly as possible, so no one would witness my freak out.
God, why did Wyatt have to be so… likeable. I’d gotten used to hating him. It was easier that way.
My chest ached, and I was positive I was having a heart attack. I rubbed at the pain with the heel of my hand and tried to sort through the riot of emotions trying to trample my insides.
The car started to get hot. The sun was warm today and without the windows down, I had started to bake. Sweat prickled on my forehead, but I still didn’t touch the manual window crank.
Instead, I glared at my phone spilling out of my purse on the passenger’s seat. I needed therapy. Or aversion therapy at the very least.
Carefully picking up my phone, I swiped my thumb over the screen until it recognized my face and opened past the lock screen. I pressed the Facebook icon and clicked on my search bar. Nolan and I weren’t friends anymore. Not in real life or on social media accounts. But his name was the first thing to appear in my search history. Pathetic. I was one hundred percent confident in how pathetic I was.
But I couldn’t help it. My social life had been reduced to coffee dates with one of my two friends and working fourteen-hour days.
He was back home dating all the girls
in Hamilton. All the girls older than eighteen and younger than sixty-six. He drew the line when they were eligible for social security.
Scrolling through Nolan’s newsfeed, I cringed at exciting pictures of him hiking, out drinking with our old circle of friends and selfies the girls he dated tagged him in. He was having the time of his life coaching and living up his youth.
I was working myself to the bone for a dream job I had to convince myself I still wanted.
Lifting my eyes, I stared at myself in the rearview mirror and forced my fragile self-esteem to call bullshit. This wasn’t a joke. And I wasn’t doing this to prove a point.
I wanted this—Sarita, food, all of it—for me. I wanted it because I didn’t know how to not want it. I wanted it so bad I could feel it in my bones, to the depths of my soul. This career was me. Sarita or no, I wasn’t going to give up on it and call it quits because my ex-boyfriend looked like he had a better night life than me.
You would think that little pep talk would make Wyatt more appealing. What if we were only having fun? I deserved a little fun, didn’t I? I deserved Facebook worthy photos and a few wild stories to share with the gossipy bitches back home.
Shaking those stupid thoughts out of my head, I started my car and pulled out on Franklin Street. I wouldn’t do that to Wyatt. I wouldn’t use him to make myself feel better.
Besides, there was more to Wyatt than I wanted to admit to myself. I wasn’t sure I could handle something casual with him. I got the distinct impression it would be like playing with fire. I would be smart for a short while, but inevitably get burned. No matter how familiar I was with the flame, he was hotter, more unpredictable, and dangerous in ways I didn’t even know existed.
No, it was easier to protect my heart from another bad boy with different aspirations. A relationship with that type of guy never ended well for me. And even though I was the one that stayed true to myself, I was the one that kept getting hurt.
At home, I planned to have another cup of coffee and relax for a few minutes before it was time to head in to work. My fake excuse about being late to work was unsubstantiated. I had at least a whole hour and a half to kill. I’d gotten my purchases put away when Dillon texted to ask if I wanted to meet Vera and her at a nearby plant nursery. I texted back that I would love to and would meet them in twenty minutes.