Page 13 of Identical


  He wraps the rope around my wrists,

  knots it tightly. Escape-proof.

  I shake my head. “Don’t.” But he does.

  Should I scream? Would anyone hear?

  Would anyone care? The obvious

  answer softens my plea. “Please?”

  Haven’t you played this game

  before? I guess I’ll have to teach

  you the rules. The proper response

  would be, “Please, sir.” Say it.

  My heart yells, “No fucking

  way.” But my brain, the part

  that understands my daddy, makes

  me acquiesce. “Please, sir.”

  He flips me onto my belly, yanks

  my legs apart. I don’t have to see

  the restraints to know they’re there.

  The ankle knots do not surprise me.

  I am helpless. Exposed. And, strangely,

  somehow I feel at home this way.

  Say it, he demands, like I should know

  he means, Please, sir. Punish me.

  Deliberate, controlled, he punishes me.

  I whisper into the pillow, “I understand.”

  I Understand

  Why Kaeleigh liked the feel of

  slicing her flesh, releasing

  bottled-up hurt. Leather snaps

  against my skin, and I remain

  still

  as stagnant water, afraid I might

  not play by his rules. This is

  a new game, and the sick

  thing is, I see quickly that I

  like

  it, might ask to play again.

  The pain is fuzzy at the edges,

  blurring toward pleasure.

  Maybe it’s the hash,

  the gentle

  arms of opium. And now

  new leather—human, Ty—

  falls softly over the heated

  welts, a soothing

  balm of

  sweat-beaded skin. But then

  heightened pain, forced inside

  me, stuffed inside me. Seared,

  branded, likely marked,

  a moan

  escapes me and Ty surges.

  After, knots loosened, a rub

  of cool eucalyptus oil persuades

  me I do want to play again. Soon.

  Kaeleigh

  Long Night

  Unable to slip into sleep,

  unable to fall into dreams,

  unable to lie completely

  still,

  snared by tangled thoughts.

  Sometimes, usually well after

  the witching hour, Raeanne

  comes to me, shares my bed

  like

  she did so long ago. She

  listens to me, soundlessly,

  doesn’t argue or judge.

  Eventually, I slip into

  the gentle

  tide of unconsciousness. But

  tonight she doesn’t appear.

  I am left to wrestle memories

  alone, comforted only by the

  balm of

  cool satin sheets. I force

  my body to relax, feel it grow

  heavy. Heavy enough to sink

  into the satin balm.

  A moan

  bubbles into my mouth,

  from I don’t know where—

  some inconceivable place where

  pleasure and joy are one.

  Not Sure Exactly When

  I managed to fall asleep,

  but it must have been eventually

  because I’m tugged like cement

  into morning by the sound

  of the telephone.

  Daddy’s feet pound

  toward the ringing.

  Hello…? Hello…?

  Okay, who the fuck is this?

  Funny, I hardly ever hear

  Daddy curse. He must be

  really pissed. The thought

  is confirmed by his footfall,

  in angry approach of my door.

  He bursts through and fear

  swallows me down. Do

  you have any idea who’s

  responsible for these hang-ups?

  One thought immediately

  crosses my mind, but I’ll be

  damned if I want to get caught

  in the middle of the brewing

  storm. “No. Should I?”

  He softens, but only a little.

  I thought maybe it was one

  of your friends. Or… white

  glare …a boyfriend?

  Like I would ever let a boy

  call here! Like I would dare

  say that. “None of my friends

  would do that, Daddy. And I

  don’t have a boyfriend.”

  Well…it’s just that this has been

  happening for several days. I

  answer, click. Maybe it’s one

  of your mom’s secret admirers.

  “Mom’s admirers aren’t so

  secret, Daddy. It’s probably

  just a solicitor or something.

  Anyway, doesn’t the number

  show up on caller ID?”

  Now why didn’t I think of that?

  His voice fairly sprays sarcasm.

  It’s a private number. Hurry

  it up now, or you’ll be late.

  The Clock Agrees

  I’m supposed to meet Brittany

  in twenty minutes. Still, I just

  can’t seem to “hurry it up.”

  Mostly because he told me to.

  I slide out of bed, shuffle

  to the bathroom, do my thing.

  Brush my teeth and hair.

  By the time I return to my

  room in search of clothes,

  Daddy is hustling toward

  the door. Come straight

  home after work. Hear me?

  Like where else would I go?

  But, of course, despite

  the serious resentment

  that blooms immediately,

  I say simply, “Okay.”

  He is all the way into the garage

  before calling over his shoulder,

  And don’t answer the phone.

  Do This, Don’t Do That

  I seriously despise the man, would do just

  about anything not to obey him, at

  least if I thought I could get

  away with it or even that

  the sure consequences

  would be sufferable.

  But when Daddy

  decides to make

  you suffer,

  it’s more

  than any

  one can

  bear.

  But He’s Gone Now

  So I’m going to do the likely

  less than intelligent thing and

  dress exactly how I want. Not

  hippie today. Frumpy? Slutty?

  Hey, maybe no clothes at all?

  Probably not a good plan.

  Who knows if Brittany’s silver

  bomber can even make it to

  school without breaking down?

  Speaking of that, she’ll be here

  soon. Better shake my tail.

  Where did that saying come

  from, anyway? I slide into

  a glam velour jogging suit. Not

  frumpy. Not slutty. Just soft

  and definitely not an outfit

  Daddy would want me to

  wear to school. Too casual.

  (Although, really not casual

  enough for a decent jog.)

  Out the door, into the cold

  morning, I’m glad I’m wearing

  sweats, if you can really call

  glam velour sweats. Up the

  sidewalk, to the corner where

  I’m supposed to meet Brittany.

  (Wasn’t sure Daddy would

  approve of that, either, should

 
he have been home to see me

  climb into a half-dilapidated

  Toyota.) Hey, maybe I defied

  him twice in one morning.

  Wouldn’t that be a coup?

  As I wait for Brittany (late,

  go figure!), my mind wraps

  around that “shake my tail”

  thing. Some deep place inside

  my brain latches onto it and

  doesn’t want to let go. Where

  did I hear that? The voice I

  don’t quite remember is low.

  Feminine. Not Mom’s, though.

  Too scratchy. So whose?

  Brittany, Finally

  And she’s not alone. Riding

  shotgun is Joel, who I know

  from drama. And in the back-

  seat, next to my apparently

  appointed place, is Shaun.

  Ian’s little brother. Great.

  Not that he’s not a nice kid,

  but sitting back there next

  to him seems somehow

  incestuous. Oh, well. It’s

  just a ride to school, right?

  Oh, hey, coos Brittany. Sorry

  I’m late, but I had to pick up

  the guys. Joel was right on

  time, but Shaun? She giggles.

  Oh, yech. Maybe Brittany

  as transportation won’t work

  out so well after all. But

  one day won’t hurt, right?

  Anyway, the bus already

  went by. My choices are

  limited. “No problem.”

  Not Being Top

  Of the hour, the radio blares.

  Hip-hop, no less. Definitely

  not my cup of tea, but hey,

  it’s not my freaking radio.

  Joel seems to like it. He jerks

  his head back and forth till

  he looks like a bobblehead

  with a really loose spring.

  Beside me, Shaun stretches

  his legs till his right knee rests

  against my left, totally creeping

  me out. Awesome song, huh?

  I jerk my knee away from his.

  “Uh, sure.” If you like songs

  without music. More like ebonic

  poetry. Before I finish the thought,

  Shaun’s leg has found its way

  back to mine. “Need more room?”

  Warmer like this, don’t you

  think? Here comes his arm.

  I turn and give him my most

  evil glare. “What are you doing?”

  Nothing. His arm withdraws, but

  only a little. Thought you’d like it.

  Irritation flares, red in my face.

  “Oh, really? And why is that?”

  He shrugs. Heard Ian talking.

  He said you’re into other guys.

  Irritation fans into anger. “Is

  that so? Well, you can just tell

  your brother for me that I am

  most certainly not into other—”

  A sudden thwunk-thwunk-thwunk

  interrupts the conversation.

  The Toyota yanks itself hard to

  the right and Brittany fights

  to stay in control. Oh, man!

  I think we’ve got a flat tire.

  Flat Barely Describes It

  The entire sidewall is gone, what’s

  left of the tread part, shredded.

  We’re not going anywhere, not on

  this tire. “Do you have a spare?”

  I dunno, but even if I do, I have

  no idea how to change it. Do

  you guys? She looks at the boys,

  who shake their heads in unison.

  We’re already late for school.

  Not much we can do but be

  later. “Okay, then. Do you have

  like AAA or something?”

  I dunno. Oh, wait. My mom

  showed me a number to call.

  It goes with our cell service.

  She leans into the car.

  As she roots through the glove

  box, I notice cars slowing a bit

  as they drive by. Something

  about four late-for-school kids,

  looking helpless as hell

  beside a useless car, barely

  pulled onto the shoulder?

  Could be it, I guess.

  Then again, you might

  think one of them would

  stop and offer to help.

  But no, they cruise on by.

  Here it is! says Brittany,

  punching at her cell phone.

  Hi. Um. I guess I need help…

  er…roadside assistance?

  If she giggles one more

  time, I’m going to push

  her out into oncoming

  traffic. We stand, stupid

  as hell, waiting for a tow

  truck. My teeth chatter,

  and Shaun dares to move

  closer. Really, really close.

  Once again, his arm tries

  to slide around my shoulder,

  and I shrink from the touch

  of his calloused skin. “No.”

  What is your fucking problem?

  I’m just trying to keep you

  warm. Oh, that’s right.

  You prefer being frigid.

  His Term or Ian’s?

  It’s going to bug me all day.

  I always thought Ian was on

  my side, that he understood,

  if not everything, that I am only

  lukewarm because I’m damaged.

  Frigid? Maybe I am. But why

  should it even be a topic

  of conversation with Shaun?

  Did Ian call me that? And did

  he really say I’m into other guys?

  Who did he say it to? And why?

  Wait…a sudden “aha” strikes.

  Madison. Would she have told

  him such a thing, sunk so low?

  And why would he believe her?

  A stronger person would go

  straight to the source, confront

  him, ask if any of the things

  his little brother had to say

  could possibly be true.

  But I could never do that.

  What if I just couldn’t stand

  to hear what he had to say?

  What if he walked away?

  What if I lost him completely?

  The Tow Truck Finally Arrives

  And I still don’t have any

  answers, despite a good forty

  minutes, standing here with

  nothing else to do but

  think.

  Shaun finally gave up on me

  and moved on to Brittany,

  who’s obviously into Joel.

  Shaun is a total clod.

  How

  can he be Ian’s brother?

  They’re about the same as

  straight sex and gay sex—

  some similarities, but

  different

  in ways that really count.

  One thing I do know is that

  if Ian deserts me, I’ll never

  repair the giant rip in my

  life.

  I don’t dare let him go.

  But how do I keep him

  without losing me?

  Who knew love

  could be

  such an enigma?

  Raeanne

  Life Is Rarely Dull

  At the Gardella house.

  Kaeleigh was late for school

  this morning. Now you might not

  think

  that should be a big problem,

  especially considering she had

  what for most would be a good

  excuse. But that’s not

  how

  things work around here. See,

  one of Daddy’s friends happened

&nbsp
; to drive by the tow truck scene

  and notice Kaeleigh. A

  different

  person might have shrugged

  it off completely. Not Hannah,

  a nursing student who lives

  down the block. I cannot for the

  life

  of me understand why she felt

  the need to call Daddy, but she

  did. No surprise it made him

  mad. But who knew he

  could be

  so unreasonable over such

  an innocent faux pas?

  Kaeleigh Came Home from School

  Not particularly worried about the tardy.

  Neither Daddy nor Mom (on those rare

  occasions she’s around to peruse progress

  reports) pays particular notice to stuff

  sent home from school. Besides, it was

  Kaeleigh’s first tardy. Ever. No big deal.

  Not, that is, until she played Daddy’s

  message, left both on her cell phone

  and on the answering machine at home.

  I heard you missed school today in favor

  of taking a little joyride with a few friends.

  I’m surprised at you. Surprised, and

  disappointed. I’d better see you at home

  when I get there. You have some explaining to do.

  And then you have to decide what your

  punishment will be. Make no mistake.

  You will be punished. When I ask what

  you think is fair, I hope you have an answer.

  By the time he was finished, she was shaking.

  I tried to tell her not to worry, that he’d cool