Christmas morning dawned with the sky’s heavy with snow. It would be a quiet day for everyone. Most of the ranch hands had left for a couple of days reprieve with just the bare minimum staying to care for the livestock. Ed was going over to Clive and Helen’s for Christmas dinner. Their kids and grandkids were in for the holiday and Helen had a house full. She had asked Lily if they wanted to come over but Lily had felt selfish, she wanted to spend Christmas in her home with her men. She had gotten up early sliding out between the warm bodies of Ethan and Caleb. Allen had slept in his room last night. They seemed to take turns who would sleep with her. Sometimes she would go to sleep with one brother only to wake up in the arms of another. She glanced at them and smiled. Her life was so full. Turning she walked silently out of the bedroom and down the stairs. The Christmas tree lit up the room when she turned it on. Sinking down on her knees she bowed her head in silent prayer.
Please if you can hear this, please let me stay this time. I love them so much. Momma and Da if you can hear me I just want to let you know I’m doing well. I’ve finally found what it means to have a love like yours. I wish you could meet them. Ethan, Caleb, and Allen have brought me so much happiness and love. Mrs. Cunnings, if you and the dads are listening, thank you for having such wonderful boys to let me share my life and love with. I miss you, Momma and Da, I’ll always be your faithful daughter. Merry Christmas.
Allen stood on the bottom step of the stairs watching as Lily knelt and bowed her head. He had never seen anyone so beautiful in all his life. He loved her so much it hurt sometimes. He knew Lily still feared her time with them was going to be short and deep down he was terrified she might be right. They had had Doc Harley check her out while she had been in the hospital and he said except for injuries she had received during her abduction everything came back normal. They had all gone ahead and had blood tests done. Today was a special day for them. He, Ethan, and Caleb were going to ask Lily to marry them. They had picked out a ring and Ethan had picked it up the day they had gone into town. They knew there was a good chance Lily could be pregnant. None of them had used any type of protection when they had made love to her which was almost daily. Lily never asked about it and she had told Doc Harley she wasn’t taking any medications including birth control. Allen closed his eyes as a sharp emotion stabbed at him when he thought of Lily big and round with their child. They didn’t care who the father was they would all be a dad. He knew Lily would be even more beautiful as she got bigger. The thought of her big and round turned him on. He felt his cock throb at the thought of being buried deep inside her.
“Lily.” Allen said quietly.
Lily gasped when she heard Allen call her name. She still couldn’t get used to how quietly he could move sometimes. Staring up at him she saw the evidence of his desire for her in his eyes and his body. He didn’t try to hide the huge hard on he had tenting the front of his pajama bottoms. Lily let her eyes roam over his bare chest. She felt a matching desire burn inside her. Lifting her hand to him, Lily beckoned him to her silently. Allen walked over, pulling her gently up and into his arms.
Not saying a word he led her over to the thick rug in front of the fireplace. Bending he began untying the ribbons holding her robe letting it drop to the floor. He ran light kisses along her jaw as he slipped first one than the other strap holding her nightgown off her shoulders so it too pooled on the floor around her leaving her bare in the warm glow of the fireplace. Lily shivered as she felt Allen’s hot breath close over one of her breasts. The feel of him sucking on her raced through her body causing her pussy to clinch in desperate desire. Groaning, she wrapped her arms around his head arching her breasts toward him for more.
Allen pulled back to look at Lily’s upturned face. He pulled her down laying her gently on the rug. Still looking at her he pushed her thighs apart and lowered his mouth to her hot mound. Lily cried out and clinched the rug with both fists as his hot mouth closed over her clit. Allen sucked and pulled on her swollen nub tasting the sweet nectar of her feminine juices. He slid his tongue in and out of her then lapped her like a kitten lapping milk. Lily began shaking as she felt him loving her, panting she tried to hold back the climax she felt building but she couldn’t. Screaming out she came hard pressing herself down against Allen’s hot mouth.
“Shit if that isn’t the best Christmas present I’ve ever seen.” Caleb said from the stairs.
Ethan looked down on Lily spread out like an offering in front of the fire. Her hair was spread out around her face framing it. Her arms were out to her sides where she gripped the thick rug and her knees were bent and spread in offering to Allen’s mouth.
Allen looked up and grinned, “I wondered when you two were going to get your asses down here. I couldn’t wait any longer to wish Lily a Merry Christmas.”
Ethan looked at Lily and smiled darkly, “I drew the short straw last night, Lily. Today is about my fantasy.”
Lily’s nipples pebbled at the thought. She knew she was about to be well and truly loved by her men. Lying like an offering before them all Lily could do was watch as Ethan and Caleb moved slowly down the stairs toward her. She licked her lips nervously. All three of them looked impressively hard. Ethan pushed his boxers down his legs. Caleb followed. Allen just grinned as he watched Lily’s nervous response.
“Lily, take off Allen’s pants and spread for him again. He has a surprise for you.” Ethan said as he walked over to pick up a present from under the tree. Lily watched him as he handed the present to Allen.
“This is for you, bro.” Allen stood so Lily could pull his pants off him. Lily looked at the other two men before turning back to Allen.
Allen took the gift with a wicked gleam in his eye, “Thanks, bro.” He waited as Lily slowly sat up and got to her knees so she could pull Allen’s pants off him. Grabbing the elastic waist she pulled slowly watching as his hard cock came free. Allen’s cock was at face level with Lily’s mouth and she couldn’t resist taking a swipe at it with her tongue. Allen jerked and groaned.
“You are a very bad girl, Lily. I think you need to be taught a lesson.” Caleb said watching as Lily’s eyes darted to him before turning back to Allen’s cock.
“If I’m going to be taught a lesson I might as well be very, very bad then.” Lily said quietly before she opened her mouth wide and took Allen’s whole length into her mouth.
“Holy shit.” Allen cursed. He jerked as Lily’s mouth clamped down on his cock.
Caleb tisked as Ethan looked on wickedly. “Yes, she is being very, very naughty. I guess we’ll just have to see what Santa put under the tree for her.” Ethan said smugly.
“Lay her down, Allen.” Caleb said. “I’ll get you the stuff you’ll need.” He headed for the downstairs bathroom.
When he came back he had a towel, a wash cloth, and a small container of warm water. He had Lily raised up so he could lay the towel under her. Lily bit her lip nervously as she watched silently.
Allen slowly opened his present to discover a razor. “Now what do you suppose this is for?” He said with a grin. Looking at Lily then the razor again he nodded to his brothers, “What do you think?”
“What?” Lily asked nervously. She stared suspiciously at the razor in Allen’s hand her eyes growing wide when she saw them looking at her dark mound. “Oh, no. Oh, no.” Just the idea had her pussy getting wetter.
“Oh, yes.” Came three responses.
“Spread your legs wide for me, baby.” Allen said softly. Lily closed her eyes and spread her legs shivering as she felt Allen gently wash her than the foam of the shaving crème before she felt the gently swipe of the blade across her mound. Allen grinned as he felt her mound clinch and wet pussy juice dripped down between her thighs, “She likes this. Merry Christmas, baby.”
Lily groaned as she felt him clean her bare mound. It was so sensitive she cried out when he ran his fingers over her.
“Damn. If she liked this present, what do you think she’ll think of some of the others?” Al
len asked in awe. He couldn’t resist bending over rubbing his mouth over the bare mound.
Lily jerked upright crying out, “Oh God, that feels so good.”
Ethan and Caleb stared at her pale mound. Crouching down on either side of her Ethan and Caleb each pushed a finger into her pussy. “Oh, hell yeah, she likes it. Caleb, I think you have a present or two under the tree.”
Caleb grinned as he pulled his finger out of Lily’s pussy and licked it looking at her wickedly. “Let’s see what Santa brought me to help teach you some manners.”
He came back a moment later with a small box. Opening it he pulled out a new set of nipple clamps. This was different from the other set he had used on her though. Lily frowned as she noticed three clamps instead of two. Why would there be three, she wondered. Not having a chance to ask, she was gently pushed back and Ethan and Allen each took one of her wrists in their big hands and pulled her wide while Caleb moved between her legs forcing her to open up for him. She moaned loudly when he clipped first one nipple than the other. It was only when he reached down between her legs and pushed back her soft folds that she realized where the third clamp was going to go. Unable to contain the gasp as he gently tightened it she groaned trying to break the hold Ethan and Allen held on her arms.
“Oh, God that feels so good. I’m on fire.” She moaned as she wiggled. Each time she moved she felt the tug on her nipples.
“Wait until I connect them. It gets even better.” Caleb said huskily. He was on fire himself. Seeing her lying there letting them do to her what they wanted was such a turn on. He had always liked to have a little of the edge when he made love but he had no idea his brothers shared his desire. The fact they did and Lily was an eager student made their relationship even more special. He pulled the chain out of the box and connected the two nipple clamps together before running it down to the one on her clit. When he tugged gently on it Lily screamed as she came again.
“Shit, listen to her.” Caleb said in awe. “I wonder if she is going to like your present as well, Ethan.”
Ethan went over to the Christmas tree and pulled a slightly larger box out from under it. Lily panted as she watched Ethan come back to stand between her legs. He slowly unwrapped it to reveal a padded paddle. He whistled as he turned it around. “Nice.”
Lily’s eyes grew large as she looked at the padded paddle. Her eyes darted from one of the men to the other. “Wait a minute. What are you going to do with that?”
“You have been a very, very naughty girl. All naughty girls’ need a good paddling every once in a while to keep them in line.” Ethan said with a mischievous grin. “Up and on your hands and knees, Lily.”
Lily shook her head. “No.”
Caleb raised an eyebrow at Lily, “Did you just say ‘no’?”
Allen ran his hands down her arm smiling, “You shouldn’t tell any of us ‘no’, baby. But, you definitely shouldn’t tell Ethan ‘no’.”
Lily looked back and forth before she slowly turned over onto her stomach. She gasped as the movement pulled on the clamps tugging on both her breasts and her clit. She got up on her hands and knees. Looking over her shoulder at Ethan, she was unable to resist wiggling her ass at him.
Ethan grinned. Turning the paddle over in his hand he smacked Lily on the ass just enough to smart but not hurt her. Lily groaned as the impact of the paddle caused her pussy to clinch. Ethan paddled her bottom until it was a soft pink. He tested her by sliding a finger into her pussy between hits. She was so wet her juices ran down the inside of her thigh. He swatted her one more time and when she groaned loudly he knew he couldn’t handle any more.
“I want her to straddle me.” Ethan choked out. Both his brothers looked as strained as he felt. Pulling Lily up, Allen and Caleb helped her position herself over Ethan. When she sank down she impaled herself on his hard, straining cock. Ethan clinched her hips as she settled all the way down in one stroke. Lily looked at Ethan’s face as she impaled herself. Ethan had thrown back his head and his mouth was slightly open as if he was in intense pleasure/pain.
Allen watched as Lily impaled herself on his brother. Turned on beyond anything he had ever experienced before he grabbed the chains on the clamps and pulled Lily forward. When she opened her mouth to gasp at the sudden tension he slid his cock into her mouth burying it as far as he could without hurting her. Lily sucked Allen teasing him with her tongue and teeth. When he went to pull out she let her teeth lightly scrap the length while when he pushed deep she let her tongue wrap around him. Allen shuttered at the combination of soft and sharp.
Caleb came up behind Lily. He watched as she gently rose up and slammed down on Ethan’s cock. Grabbing her by the back of her neck Caleb bent her forward and guided his cock to her tight ring. Ever since he had watched Allen fucking her there he knew he had to have a turn. She was so wet he didn’t need lube. Sliding slowly into her he groaned when she pushed back against him taking him deeper. He lost what little control he had and began pumping her hard and fast. When she slammed down hard on Ethan he roared out his release gripping her hips to keep her still while Caleb pumped furiously in her ass. Ethan could feel every move his brother made through the thin barrier and it was too much. He shuddered as he pressed her down hard against him pumping his hot seed into her womb. He hoped he was successful in giving her a child. He wanted to see her growing big.
Caleb strained. He had felt Ethan’s release and increased his strokes, the sounds of his fleshing hitting Lily echoing throughout the room. His heavy pants matched Lily’s and Ethan’s. As he came he pushed deep, releasing his seed into Lily’s body at the same time he felt her cries as she came. When she came he felt her body spasm around his cock.
“Shit. Shit.” Caleb and Ethan both said as their eyes’ widen in surprise to feel Lily milk a little more out of them.
Allen’s loud cry filled the room a moment later as he jerked and threw his head back in release as Lily swallowed his hot cum. He fell back on his heels and bowed his head as he panted. He didn’t know what had just happened but it had been the most incredible experience of his life. He had always held a part of himself back but he hadn’t been able to this time. It was as if Lily had pulled his soul out of his body and into hers. It shook him to the very core of his being. He looked down at Lily’s flushed face and knew he would never be the same. He would never be able to live without her. She had taken a piece of him. She had taken his heart.
Caleb had been the one to gently pick Lily up and carried her upstairs to the master bathroom where he gently bathed her and dressed her. When he was done he carried her back downstairs despite her insistence she could walk. He didn’t want to let her go. He couldn’t let her go. He needed to touch her. His brothers seemed to understand something had changed inside him. He had always been the one who could walk away. He was the one who always had a wall between him and the world. They seemed to sense his vulnerability. They seemed to understand he was in unfamiliar territory and needed Lily’s reassurance everything would be alright.
Ethan fixed them a light breakfast and brought it into the living room to eat in front of the fire. Christmas music played softly in the background. When Lily had looked out the big windows she saw it had started to snow. She laughed as she listened to the men tell stories of Christmas’ past. She handed out the presents she had made for each of the men. She didn’t have much money and didn’t want to spend theirs so she had made things the way they did when she was a child. She shared some of the Christmas’ she had shared with her parents, crying a little as she remembered. Caleb had held her close while Ethan and Allen had scooted closer. Finally, there was just one present left under the tree. It was a small box with Lily’s name on it. Allen handed it to Caleb. They had decided they would flip to see who would be the one to legally marry Lily. Caleb had won the toss. It didn’t matter to any of them who had won because to them she would be married to all three of them.
Caleb took the box from Allen looking down at it a moment before he ha
nded it to Lily. “This is for you from all of us.”
Lily looked at Caleb then down at the box she held. She slowly opened it. It was a small jeweler’s box. Opening it she saw a beautiful sapphire and diamond ring. Drawing in a breath, she raised tear filled eyes to Caleb’s again.
Caleb reached over and gently picked up Lily’s hand, “Lily, will you marry us? You will be official married to me. We will have a small informal wedding ceremony where you’ll marry all of us.”
Caleb tried to keep his fear from showing. He was terrified she would turn them down. He knew she still didn’t feel like she was going to get to stay with them but they were just as determined she would. They wanted forever with her.