Devin shook her head. “Margaret isn’t after revenge. She’s showing us what can happen if hatred and fear lead to persecution so we can stop it from happening again. Maybe our killer is driven by prejudice and fear, or maybe he has some sick, twisted reason for wanting to drive others to feel that way.”
“Maybe. But we still need to figure out how the pentagrams fit in. If they were created by—and perhaps bought by—the same person...”
“You really think a schoolteacher—”
“I think she might have sold them to a store that sold them to the killer.”
“Thirteen years ago, she was still teaching.”
He nodded. “Yes, she was—right here in the area.”
Devin sat back, frustrated. “You do realize that Boston is only twenty miles away.”
“This is local,” he said.
“How do you know?”
“Because something about it is personal. What happened in the past, what’s happening now...there’s a personal dimension to both of them.”
His phone rang just as he and Devin were finishing their lunch. It was Sam, telling him the rest of them were five minutes from the site. They all met up by the hill, and he helped Sam drag the equipment out of their SUV, then explained how to use everything. Then they paired up―Sam and Jenna, Jane and Angela, and he and Devin―and began the search.
“Shall we try over there?” he asked Devin, pointing toward the crevice.
“No,” she said softly. “If we find someone there...well, we might prove that this is Gallows Hill, but for now we’re looking for Margaret’s grave. For some reason I think it’s over that way, beyond the trees.”
She led them to the area she had in mind, and they created a primitive grid and then worked in silence for about an hour.
Suddenly Angela cried out, “Over here! We’ve got something.”
Everyone ran over to look at the radar screen. He could see the shapes of bones—badly disarticulated but unmistakable―with something else in the center.
Human bones.
Devin had been right.
He looked up and realized she wasn’t with them. He turned back and saw that she was standing in the center of a group of trees with a field of last year’s fallen leaves beneath them.
“I’ll get shovels,” Sam said.
Angela pointed at the screen. “It’s amazing. Rocky—there, that looks like the skull. And the bones...some are missing, I think, but those look like ribs.”
“How sad,” Jane murmured.
“Devin?” Rocky called, turning back toward her again.
She hadn’t moved.
She didn’t seem to hear him.
He remembered her earlier entranced state and, worried, hurried over to her.
She spoke at last, just before he reached her.
“Slow down,” she told him.
He did, moving carefully. “Devin,” he asked, “what is it?”
She turned to him. Her blue eyes seemed enormous, her expression one of incredible sadness.
“I’ve found someone else,” she said.
And she had.
The woman was laid out like the others, with arms and legs outstretched, her head forming the top of the star. Bracken and fallen leaves still hid most of her, and she hadn’t yet begun to decay, so they hadn’t detected the scent of death.
She had been young, with dark hair. She was wearing jeans and a sweater, and she looked almost as if she’d lain down to make angels in the leaves.
But the thread of blood around her neck gave the lie to that story.
As did the pentagram lying on her chest, glinting through the leaves.
11
Devin was certain that Jack Grail was looking at her with suspicion, even though Rocky had explained to Jack that they had been searching for a long-dead woman, not another recent victim.
The day had become filled with crime scene technicians, the Boston M.E. and his crew and a multitude of police—state and local—along with representatives from the museum to assist in the investigation of the bones and, of course, the FBI team. Officers from a number of the small area towns kept crowd control running smoothly.
Rocky and the rest of the Krewe had focused on the latest murder victim until Jack and his men had arrived to join them.
Now, though Jack was being polite and hadn’t even suggested that he intended to take her down to the station for questioning, much less arrest her, he seemed to be asking the same questions over and over again.
“Devin, I still don’t understand—why this sudden interest in quite literally digging up a woman who’s been all but lost to history? And what made you think someone would kill her and bury her here, where, if you’re right, they were hanging the condemned witches? And, you, Rocky! What the hell were you doing focusing a full FBI team on a woman who died hundreds of years ago just because Devin got caught up in some historical wild-goose chase, when we have our own murders to solve?”
“Why the hell shouldn’t I?” Rocky demanded, his tone irritated. “It’s not like we’ve been getting anywhere with the current case, and the whole witchcraft-Wiccan connection seems to tie the present to the past, don’t you think? And the fact that we found another victim here on what may very well be the real Gallows Hill seems like a pretty strong indication I’m right.”
“But you were looking for a victim murdered three hundred years ago!” Jack said. “It was pure luck that you—that Devin—stumbled on another body. Not to mention that there were no witches in 1692,” Jack said. “No real witches, anyway.”
“No, but we wouldn’t have the Wiccan community we have here now if it hadn’t been for the witch trials,” Devin said. “There’s a connection here, we just don’t know what it is yet. Maybe revenge.”
“You think someone is killing people over a three-hundred-year-old grudge?” Jack said incredulously. “Come on, you grew up here. What have the descendants of the victims done? They’ve demanded that their ancestors be pardoned—that’s what they’ve done. They haven’t gone running around killing other innocent people.”
“Jack, I don’t know. I don’t have any answers—not yet. But I was researching, and―”
“Stop researching,” Jack snapped.
“Dammit, Jack!” Rocky told him. She could see that Rocky was becoming heated in her defense, and despite everything, it filled her with warmth.
“Hey,” she said softly. “I know you guys are both the pros and I’m just a writer, but I can’t help thinking that if you can find the motive, it will help you find the killer.”
“I hope so,” Jack said. “Because now we have a third body on our hands.”
“Fourth body,” Rocky said.
Jack looked at him.
“Whoever is doing this killed Melissa Wilson,” Rocky said flatly.
Jack stared at him, then nodded slowly. “Four,” he agreed. “No ID on her, either. I hope to hell we don’t have another Jane Doe,” he said, shaking his head and walking away.
Rocky looked at Devin. For a moment she thought even he was looking at her with suspicion. But then he said, “Don’t let him get to you. He’s just being a good cop.” He tried a smile. “Problem is, he’s a cop who doesn’t see ghosts.”
“I was thinking earlier that we’d be the first ones hanged.”
He offered her a wry grin. “I’m sure the Puritans would have seen our ability as witchcraft, so I guess you’re right.”
“I did have a great-great-great-whatever-grandmother who was arrested as a witch. She survived until Governor Phipps’s wife was accused and he outlawed the use of spectral evidence.” She smiled. “Remember? They believed that witches could send themselves out as specters to harm others.”
She heard excited murmurings coming from the people clustered around the old grave and walked over to see what they had discovered, only half-aware that Rocky was right behind her. She saw that they had abandoned their shovels and were using delicate brushes to uncover the bones themselves.
Others might debate her identity, but Devin knew it was Margaret Nottingham in that grave.
She had been buried deeply. Whoever had dug her grave hadn’t wanted her to be found, not by the residents of Salem and not by any roving animals that might have disturbed her rest.
“It appears that she was buried on her back,” one of the anthropologists said, his tone excited, while another of the group began snapping pictures. “From the way the bones have been arranged—see the wrist there, and the phalanges, the fingers—her arms were crossed over her chest, as they would have been in a good Christian burial. And there’s something there on her chest. Maybe a cross?”
Rocky reached into his back pocket for a plastic evidence bag. Without a word, he pushed through the group around the grave and jumped down into the spacious hole they had dug around the corpse. Before anyone had a chance to protest he used the evidence bag like a glove and reached for the object. Like the bones themselves, it was encrusted in dirt, but he studied it carefully before inverting the evidence bag around it.
He hoisted himself up out of the hole, his expression unreadable.
“What is it?” Devin asked.
“A pentagram,” he said quietly.
* * *
The dead woman was Barbara Benton, from Ohio. She had come to Salem on vacation with several friends. She was twenty-seven years old, single and the manager of a chain clothing store.
The two friends she had come to town with—Juliet Manson and Gail Billet—had seen her picture on the news and had come forward to identify her.
Jack was calling her parents.
Rocky took the job of meeting with the two friends to find out what he could about Barbara’s activities once she’d arrived in Salem. Because he was afraid for her to be alone, he left Devin with Jane and Angela. She was going to go back to the hotel with them, so they could do further research into Margaret Nottingham and her family. Rocky had kept the medallion and sent it to the lab so it could be cleaned and compared with the others for style, chemical makeup and historical context. Jenna and Sam were waiting at the lab to reclaim it as soon as it was ready.
Rocky met Juliet and Gail at their hotel, a small historic building right in town. They were both nearly hysterical, and getting them to calm down enough to answer questions wasn’t easy. How could they answer questions? She was dead. Barbara was dead.
“And we owe it to her, her parents and you to bring her killer to justice,” he told them.
Juliet was dark haired with red-rimmed brown eyes, and she fought to hold back her tears. “She was—she was the best.”
“This whole trip was her idea. She wanted to explore her roots,” Gail said. She was a redhead with freckles that were nearly lost against the red blotches crying had left on her skin.
“Her roots?” Rocky asked.
Juliet nodded. “Her family moved to the Midwest sometime in the 1900s. But she could trace her dad’s family all the way back here. She said she had a great-great-whatever who’d lived here during the witch trials.”
“One of the condemned?” Rocky asked.
“No, no, just someone who lived here. But Barbara always wanted to come here. We’d planned this trip for years,” Juliet said.
“It was her dream trip,” Gail told him. And then she began to sob again, and Juliet put her arms around her and they sobbed together.
Rocky waited. When their crying eased again he asked, “When did you last see her?”
“Last night—on Essex Street,” Gail said. “We were at the bar on the corner...almost directly across from the hotel.” She winced. “This was a bad time for her. Her fiancé was killed overseas a few months ago. He was in the service. But being here, taking a trip she’d dreamed of...she finally seemed to be having a good time again. She was talking about how she wanted to go and see where her family had lived.”
“Somewhere in Danvers,” Juliet added.
“And then what? Did you all go back to the hotel together?”
He looked at the two of them as they both went pale, stared at each other and burst into tears again.
“We did. But then she went back to the bar for her phone,” Juliet said.
“She thought she’d left it on the table,” Gail explained.
“And that’s the last time you saw her? Didn’t you worry when she didn’t come back to the room?” he asked.
“She was next door—she had her own room,” Juliet said. “This place is historic and cool, but the rooms are small, and the bathroom... She thought that we should have two bathrooms between us.”
“When she wasn’t there this morning, we just thought she’d gone out early,” Juliet said.
“She wanted to explore the archives,” Gail said. “Do some research into her family.”
“And she was afraid we’d be bored. We were going to spend the morning on our own today, shop, do what we wanted, then meet up for dinner,” Juliet said.
“And then we saw her picture on TV!” Gail said with a sob.
“What time was it?” Rocky asked them.
“Not that long ago...I guess about four this afternoon,” Juliet said.
“I mean last night. What time did you leave the bar?”
“Oh. Late,” Gail said. “We had such a great day, so we were just relaxing over a beer, you know, and―”
“What time did you leave the bar?” Rocky persisted gently.
Juliet turned to Gail. “What do you think? Maybe near midnight?”
“That sounds right. We’d been on a ghost tour,” Gail explained.
“We had such a great guide,” Juliet said, tears welling in her eyes again.
“Barbara loved him,” Gail agreed.
“Do you remember his name?” Rocky asked.
“Oh yes, Brent. His name was Brent,” Gail said. “Brent Corbin.”
* * *
“I know that we work in mysterious ways,” Angela said, sitting across the table from Devin in the suite the agents had taken, “but it’s going to be difficult to solve a three-hundred-year-old murder.”
Jane and Angela were at their computers; Devin had a book open in front of her, having gotten them to stop at one of her favorite shops to pick up a few books, this one on the symbology and use of the pentagram through history.
“Very difficult. And we’re not doing so well on finding the current killer, either,” Jane said.
“And maybe the two cases have nothing to do with each other,” Devin murmured dejectedly. “I don’t know. I heard Margaret Nottingham—the woman whose grave we found today, I’m certain of it―the night I found the victim near my house. And then I kept dreaming about Gallows Hill—if that even is Gallows Hill. Maybe I was just being influenced by the things I’d heard all my life, stories I’d read and stored in the back of my memory, or...”
“Let’s assume that it does mean something,” Angela said. “The ghost came to your house and found you. She somehow knew that she could reach you, and she led you to our Jane Doe. And whatever formed the impetus for your dreams, I think we have to accept those as true, as well, given what we—you—found today. So now we know that your ghost, Margaret, was killed, then buried—with a pentagram, just like our recent victims—on what seems to be Gallows Hill, where our newest victim was also found. So, yes, that does suggest that the current murders are related in some way to what happened to her during the witch trials.”
Devin looked over at Angela and Jane. “Their friend—Rocky and Jack’s friend—who was murdered thirteen years ago, she was from here, right? Did her family go back to the days of the witch trials?”
The other two women looked at each other, then shook their heads. “We’ve read the reports, of course,” Angela said. “But there was nothing in them about her family history.”
“I guess we can wait and ask Rocky,” Devin said.
“Or we can look it up online,” Jane said.
“Do you have a deep, dark, secret federal way to find information?” Devin teased
.
“Sometimes,” Jane said, laughing, “and sometimes I just go to the same ancestry sites everyone else uses.”
She took Melissa’s file from the stack in front of her on the table, consulted it, then started typing information into her computer. Several minutes went by. Both Angela and Devin watched her without speaking.
“Melissa Wilson’s mother was a Harte,” Jane said at last. “The first Harte arrived in Boston in 1630. His son moved to Salem Village in 1660. The male line came to a halt with Melissa Wilson’s mother’s father,” Jane said.
“I don’t remember anyone named Harte being associated with the trials,” Devin said.
“I don’t know the history like you do,” Jane said, “but neither do I. Of course, there were plenty of families who weren’t accused and didn’t take part in the persecutions.”
“Let’s look up Carly Henderson,” Angela suggested.
“All right, good idea,” Jane murmured.
She leafed through the files on the table for the right one and started typing again.
Again, they were silent as they waited. Then Jane let out a long breath and looked over at the two of them.
“This one is more complicated. Carly’s grandmother was from Los Angeles. Her father was from Providence. But his mother was from Andover, Massachusetts, and...” She looked up and nodded grimly. “Yes, her family dates back to the time of the trials, as well. Their family name was Manchester.”
“Manchester,” Devin murmured.
“Mean anything to you?” Jane asked.
Devin shook her head.
“Well, these two are related if only because of their family histories,” Jane said.
“We need an ID on our Jane Doe,” Angela said. “Then we can see if she has family ties to the area, too. If she herself was from the area, someone should have noticed by now that she’s missing.”
“What about the new victim?” Devin asked.
“We don’t have much of a file on her yet. I could be spinning my wheels and not come up with anything useful,” Jane said. “Then again, I spend half my life spinning my wheels, because searching for the truth is almost always like hunting for a needle in a haystack.” She pulled over another file and started typing again.