Page 33
"Why would I want her dead?"
"Thats easy. You wanted her apartment. "
"Look around you," she said. "Ive already got an apartment. Ground floor, no stairs to climb. What did I need with hers?"
"I spent a lot of time downtown today. Most of the morning and a good part of the afternoon. Its hard to chase things through the municipal record system, but if you know how to do it and what youre looking for, theres a lot you can find out. I found out who owns this building. An outfit called Daskap Realty Corp. "
"I could have told you that. "
"I also found out who owns Daskap. A woman named Wilma Rosser. I dont suppose it would be terribly hard to prove that Wilma Rosser and Willa Rossiter are the same person. You bought the building and moved in, but you told everybody that you were just the super, that you got the apartment in return for your services. "
"You have to do that," she said. "No landlord can live on the premises unless you hide the fact from your tenants. Otherwise theyre after you all the time for one thing or another. I had to be able to shrug and say the landlord says no or I cant reach the landlord or whatever I had to say. "
"It must have been tough," I said. "Trying to generate a positive cash flow here, with all of the tenants paying rent way below market. "
"It is tough," she admitted. "The woman you mentioned, Gertrude Grod. She was rent-controlled, of course. Her annual rent came to less than what it cost to heat her place during the winter. But you cant believe Id kill her because of that. "
"Her among others. You dont own just this building. Youre the principal in two other corporations besides Daskap. One of them, also owned ultimately by Wilma Rosser, owns the building next door. Another, owned by W. P. Taggart, owns two buildings across the street, the ones where youre the superintendent. Wilma P. Rosser was divorced from Elroy Hugh Taggart three years ago in New Mexico. "
"I got in the habit of using different names. My political background and all. "
"The buildings across the street have been a very unsafe place to live since you bought them. Five people have died over there in the past year and a half. One was a suicide. They found her with her head in the oven. The rest all died of natural causes. Heart attacks, respiratory failure. When frail old people die alone, no one looks too hard to see what did it. You can smother an old man in his sleep, you can haul an old lady across the floor and leave her with her head in the gas oven. Thats a little dangerous because theres always the possibility of an explosion, and you wouldnt want to blow up the building just to kill a tenant. Thats probably why you only used that method once. "
"Theres no evidence of any of this," she said. "Old people die all the time. Its not my fault if the actuarial tables caught up with some of my tenants. "
"They were all full of chloral hydrate, Willa. "
She started to say something. Her mouth opened, but something stopped the words. She breathed heavily, in and out, and then her hand moved to her mouth and her index finger rubbed at the gum above the two false teeth, replacements for the ones shed lost in Chicago. She sighed again, heavily, and something went out of her face and the set of her shoulders.
She picked up her coffee cup, took it over to the sink and emptied it. She got the bottle of Teachers from the cabinet and filled the cup. She drank deeply and shuddered. "God," she said, "you must miss this stuff. "
"Sometimes. "
"Id miss it. Matt, they were just waiting to die, just hanging on and hanging on. "
"And you were doing them a favor. "
"I was doing everybody a favor, myself included. There are twenty-four apartments in this building, all with pretty much the same layout. Renovated and sold as co-ops, every apartment in the building would bring a minimum of a hundred and twenty-five thousand dollars. You could probably get a little more for the front ones. Theyre a little nicer, theyre airier, the lights better. Maybe you could up the numbers a little if you did a really nice renovation. Do you know what that comes to?"
"Two million dollars?"
"Closer to three. Thats for each building. Buying them cost me every cent I inherited from my parents, and theyre mortgaged to the hilt. The rent roll barely covers payments and taxes and maintenance. I have a few tenants in each building who are paying close to market, and otherwise I couldnt keep the buildings. Matt, do you think its fair that a landlord has to subsidize tenants by letting them hang on to an apartment for a tenth of what its worth?"
"Of course not. The fair thing is for them to die and for you to make twelve million dollars. "
"I wouldnt be making that much. Once Ive got a large percentage of vacant apartments I can sell the buildings to somebody who specializes in co-op conversions. If everything comes together the way it should, my profit will be about a million dollars a building. "
"So youll make four million. "
"I might hang on to one of the buildings. Im not sure, I havent decided. But either way Ill make a lot of money. "
"It sounds like a lot to me. "
"Its actually less than it sounds like. A millionaire used to be a really rich person. Now when the top prize in a lottery is a million dollars its considered small-time. But I could live nicely on a couple of million dollars. "
"Its a shame you wont be able to. "
"Why wont I?" She reached out and took my hand, and I felt her energy. "Matt, there wont be any more killings. That ended a long time ago. "
"A tenant in this building died not two months ago. "
"In this building? Matt, that was Carl White, he died of cancer, for Gods sake!"
"He was full of chloral, Willa. "
Her shoulders sagged. "He was dying of cancer," she said. "He would have died of his own accord in another month or two. He was in pain all the time. " She raised her eyes to mine. "You can believe what you want about me, Matt. You can think Im the reincarnation of Lucrezia Borgia, but you really cant turn Carl Whites death into a murder for gain. All I did was lose whatever rent he would have paid in however many months of life hed have had left to him. "
"Then why did you kill him?"
"Youll try to find a way to twist this, but it was an act of mercy. "
"What about Eddie Dunphy? Was that an act of mercy?"
"Oh, God," she said. "That was the only one I regret. The others were people who would have killed themselves if theyd had the wit to think of it. No, Eddie wasnt an act of mercy. Killing him was an act of self-preservation. "
"You were afraid he would talk. "
"I knew he would talk. He actually waltzed in here and told me he would talk. He was in AA, the poor damned fool, and he was babbling like some kind of religious convert who had Jesus Christ appear to him on the side of his toaster oven. He said he had to sit down with someone and tell him everything, but that I didnt have anything to worry about because he would keep my name out of it. I killed somebody in my building so the landlady could get her apartment, but I wont tell you who put me up to it. He said the person he was going to tell wouldnt tell anyone. "
"He was right. I wouldnt have. "
"Youd have overlooked multiple homicide?"
I nodded. "Id have been breaking the law, but it wouldnt be the first law I ever broke or the first homicide I overlooked. God never appointed me to go around the world righting wrongs. Im not a priest, but anything he said to me would have been under the seal of the confessional as far as I was concerned. I told him Id keep his confidence and I would have. "
"Will you keep mine?" She moved closer to me, and her hands fastened first on my wrists, then moved to my forearms. "Matt," she said, "I invited you in here the first day to find out how much you knew. But I didnt have to take you to bed to manage that. I went to bed with you because I wanted to. "
I didnt say anything.
"I didnt count on falling in love with you," she said, "but it happened. I feel foolish saying it now because youll twist it, but it happens to be the truth. I dont know if youre in love with me
. I think you were starting to be, and I think thats why youre angry with me now. But theres been something real and strong between us from the beginning, and I feel it now, and I know you do, too. Dont you?"
"I dont know what I feel. "
"I think you do. And youre a good influence on me, youve already got me making real coffee. Matt, why dont you give us a chance?"
"How can I do that?"
"Its the easiest thing in the world. All you have to do is forget everything we said tonight. Matt, you just told me you werent put on the planet to right all wrongs. Youd have let it go if Eddie had told you about it. Why cant you do as much for me?"
"I dont know. "
"Why not?" She leaned a little closer, and I could smell the scotch on her breath, and remember how her mouth tasted. She said, "Matt, Im not going to kill anybody else. Thats over forever, I swear it is. And theres no real proof I ever killed anyone, is there? A couple of people had a non-lethal dose of a common drug in their systems. Nobody can prove I gave it to them. Nobody can even prove I had it in my possession. "
"I copied the label the other day. Ive got the number of the prescription, the issuing pharmacy, the date of issue, the physicians name-"
"The doctor will tell you I have trouble getting to sleep. I bought the chloral for my own consumption. Matt, theres no real physical evidence. And Im a respectable citizen, Im a property owner, I can afford good lawyers. How good a case could they make against me when all they have is circumstantial evidence?"
"Thats a good question. "
"And why should we go through all of that?" She laid a hand on my cheek, stroked along the grain of my beard. "Matt, darling, were both tense, its all crazy, its a crazy day. Why dont we go to bed? Right now, the two of us, why dont we take off our clothes and go to bed and see how we feel afterward. How does that sound to you?"
"Tell me how you killed him, Willa. "
"I swear he never felt a thing, he never knew what was happening. I went up to his room to talk with him. He let me in. I gave him a cup of tea and put the drops in it. Then I came back downstairs, and when I went up again later he was sleeping like a lamb. "
"And what did you do?"
"What you said. It was clever of you to figure it out. Youre a good detective. "
"Howd you manage it?"
"He was already stripped. All he was wearing was the T-shirt. I got the clothesline hooked up, and then I sat him up and fixed the noose around his neck. He never woke up. I just pulled up on the clothesline and let his own body weight shut off his oxygen. Thats all. "
"And Mrs. Grod?"
"It was the way you figured it. I got her to take the chloral and I unlocked her window gates. I didnt kill her. Eddie did that. He made it look like a struggle, too, and he locked the doors from inside and went back downstairs on the fire escape. Matt, they were all tired of life, the ones I killed. I just gave them a hand in the direction they were already heading. "