“No, sir.”
“I haven’t cried since. Not once. I don’t know if I’m capable of crying now.”
“So the system really works?”
“Oh, the system works fine, Poteete.”
“I hope that happens to me, sir.”
“Cry at night, Poteete. Cry in the latrine or when you’re taking a shower. But please don’t cry in front of them or you’ll be back with your father in . . . where s your hometown?”
“Sir, my hometown is Pickens, South Carolina, sir.”
“Otherwise, you’ll spend a long winter in Pickens with your father not talking to you.”
“I’ll never go back to Pickens if I quit.”
“I wouldn’t go back to Pickens if I stayed,” I answered. “But I wanted to warn you, Poteete. They have you marked now. I’ll do what I can to help you but I’m not much respected for my love of the plebe system and if they see me helping you too much, then they’ll be even tougher on you. You’ve got to become invisible to them, blend in with the background. Do everything they tell you to do. Look like you love doing it whether it’s washing down the quadrangle with a toothbrush or doing a hundred pushups. They’ve sent more than one freshman packing because of a nervous breakdown.”
“If you hate it so much, sir, why did you stay?” Poteete asked.
“Fuck you, Poteete,” I flared back. “You ain’t my analyst. I stayed for the same reason you want to stay. The upholding of the McLean tradition. That kind of crap. And do you know something else, Poteete? I was a coward. I couldn’t face the shame of having quit this dump. I envied those kids who walked out of here and started new lives that had nothing to do with the Institute or the system or the Corps. The irony of it all, Poteete, the goddam hilarious irony is that the rest of the world, if they could only know about this place, would think everybody connected with it was stark raving mad.”
Poteete looked at me suspiciously and asked, “You don’t believe in the system, Mr. McLean?”
“That’s right, dumbhead,” I answered him back meeting his gaze directly. “I don’t believe in the system.”
“Then I don’t think I should be around you, sir,” he said. “I believe in the system, sir.”
“Then I suggest you go find some members of the cadre, Poteete. They’ll be glad to indoctrinate you fully in its glories and triumphs.”
“I appreciate your trying to help, sir. I really do. But I want to be an Institute man more than anything in the world.”
“Good. Then I’m going to tell Snipes that you think he’s a zit-faced cocksucker. Then Snipes will help you to become a much better Institute man than you might have become talking to softies like me.”
“You misunderstand me, Mr. McLean. Everyone misunderstands me here.”
“I’m not going to talk to Snipes, Poteete. I break out into hives every time I see him draw a level breath.”
“Will that be all, sir?” Poteete asked, bracing again.
I put my hand on his shoulder and walked him to the door.
“Just remember this, Poteete. For what it is worth. And this is coming from a guy who doesn’t believe in the system. If you keep on crying, you won’t make it. They’ll run you out. Good luck. And come up here if you ever want the pressure off. I’ve got real nice roommates.”
“Thank you, sir. I’ll do my best, sir.”
“I hope you make it, Poteete. I hope you make it for yourself and not that prick father from Pickens, South Carolina.”
“Sir, don’t you call my father a prick,” Poteete warned.
“What will you do about it if I do, dumbhead?” I asked curiously.
“I’ll have to fight you, sir,” Poteete answered. He looked utterly pathetic as he stood there bracing and issuing me a challenge at the same time.
“Very good. Your father is not a prick. I’m sorry. Your father is a gift of the Magi. You’d have to fight me. Goddam, Poteete, you might make it after all.”
“I’ll never quit, Mr. McLean. Good night, sir. Thanks for the advice. I know you were only trying to help me.”
“Thanks for not kicking my ass, Poteete. My whole goddam life just flashed before me when you threatened physical harm. Remember, you’ve got to quit crying. Otherwise, you’re gone, Poteete. Long gone.”
Chapter Thirteen
On Sunday, I found the white gate on Stoll’s Alley that led down a narrow brick path to the garden of Annie Kate’s house on Church Street. There was a runaway luxuriance to the garden’s ruined profusion that made it seem sinister instead of tranquil. It was a surprising touch of wilderness in the most ardently civilized acreage in South Carolina and a perfect place for a secret rendezvous.
I saw Annie Kate sitting on a small bench behind an unoccupied carriage house, watching me through her sunglasses. An arbor of vegetation enclosed her as she waited with her hands inside her raincoat pockets. Even in the middle of a late August day, it was cool in the untended shade. She smiled at me and motioned for me to come quickly to her side, and I realized that I was visible from at least two windows of the main house. Quickly, I made my way to her. We shone, she in her faded raincoat and I in my summer uniform, like two ivory chess pieces in the green tumult of her garden.
“You wore that silly nose again,” she said.
“It breathes well and I decided to keep it.”
“I do hope you reconsider your decision,” she replied, adjusting her scarf.
“You’re wearing a different scarf,” I said.
“I’m glad you noticed. This is my favorite. The one I wore that night we met is such a tacky thing. I’ve always detested it. Tell me everything you did this week. Every single thing and don’t leave out a single detail. I’ve been so bored I almost read a book. Why didn’t you call me?”
“I don’t have your number. I don’t know your last name. And I didn’t know you wanted me to call you.”
“You can’t call me. Mother would be furious. Did you think about calling me? Did you want to call me?”
“Yes, I wanted to call you.”
“If you’d really wanted to call me, you’d have found a way. If you had a true romantic temperament, you’d have come here at night, climbed to my bedroom window on a ladder, and begged me to give you my telephone number,” she whispered. Since I could not see her eyes, I didn’t know if Annie Kate was teasing me or slightly out of her mind. I had never met a Southern girl who talked so boldly in my entire life and would have denied the existence of such a desperately forward creature had someone described her in accurate detail.
“That’s all I need,” I answered. “To be shot off a ladder while trying to break into a house South of Broad.”
“I’ve been so lonely this week I could’ve killed myself and never given it a second thought,” she said, speaking more to herself than to me. “When I’m alone all I can do is think and I absolutely hate to think. Especially now.”
“You look like you’ve been thinking long, deep thoughts on this bench.”
“People who go around thinking deep thoughts are usually pretentious, silly things who have no sense of who they are. I bet you sit around thinking all the time. Boys from good families are out to have good times. They detest deep thoughts as much as I do. But they’re serious about the important things.”
Taking a seat beside her, I asked, “Such as?”
“Such as preserving history, selling real estate, making a good living for their families, hiring a good staff, and sending their children to the proper schools. Charleston boys always give a good account of themselves.”
“Speaking of hiring a good staff,” I said, looking around the garden, “who’s your gardener? Johnny Appleseed or the Jolly Green Giant?”
“I’m not going to let you make me mad today,” she said. “Did you bring me a flower, Will, or a box of candy, or some other nice, thoughtful presentable?”
“No, I didn’t bring you anything,” I answered, mad at myself for not having thought of it.
“No
wonder you don’t have any girl friends,” she pouted. “Not only do you have a funny nose, but I always expect that the dear sweet boys in my life will bring me a presentable when they come to my door.”
“Maybe if I was coming to your door, it would be different,” I said, my voice rising, “but I’m coming to your back yard garden. I’m not sitting in your drawing room nibbling on bennie wafers and sweets, I’m sitting beneath an eight-foot-high camellia bush and three palmetto trees. No, Annie Kate, I didn’t bring you a goddam presentable.”
She was smiling again, and her voice was teasing as she said in a flawless self-parody, “A gentleman would never, under any circumstance, use such language in front of a lady. Especially a lady of my delicate coloring and breathtaking beauty. We Charleston girls are fragile, Will. Profanity bruises us.”
“Annie Kate, do you always talk and act like you’re a complete idiot?”
“How dare you to insult me like that in my own house,” she bristled. “If you don’t understand what I’m doing, Will, then you shouldn’t ever be around women at all. I’ve been around men long enough to know that all they want is a woman who’ll make them feel smart and handsome and superior. I’ve watched women flirt with men all my life, and I’ve become goddam good at playing the coquette. In case you haven’t noticed.”
“Please,” I said. “I’m a cadet. Profanity bruises me.”
“No girl in her right mind would ever put up with someone like you. You might as well declare yourself to be a homosexual.”
“That was a joke.”
“Your calling me an idiot was not a joke.”
“I didn’t call you an idiot. I said that sometimes you talked and acted like you were an idiot.”
“I’m brighter than anyone who goes to that second-rate college you go to. The Institute’s a rinky-dink college for cretins who weren’t smart enough to get into a military academy. A boy of intelligence wouldn’t think of going there.”
“You can’t offend me by cutting down the Institute,” I told her truthfully. “I’m impervious to all criticism of my alma mater.”
“You ought to have more loyalty. I detest disloyal people. I’m very well known for my loyalty.”
“What are you loyal to?” I asked.
“My family. My city. My heritage. My religious beliefs.”
“And Santa Barbara, your college,” I added.
She whirled on me furiously and said, “God don’t like ugly, Will McLean. He doesn’t like ugliness and he doesn’t forgive ugliness and you’re acting like just about the ugliest human being I’ve ever met. Most girls I know have too much pride to be seen with a crude, nasty cadet like you.”
“You’re not being seen with me. We’re hiding in a garden behind a carriage house. You’d have to have a pack of bloodhounds to flush us out of this jungle.”
“No one forced you to come, Will, and I certainly couldn’t care less whether you stay or not,” Annie Kate said. A freeze had entered her voice. I stood up and walked in front of her.
“I’m not very good at talking to girls, Annie Kate. I tried to tell you that. I don’t know why it always ends up like this when we talk. I was really looking forward to seeing you. I was looking forward to it all week because . . . because it was so strange and I thought something wonderful could come out of our meeting.”
“Nothing wonderful can come from our meeting. I can promise you that. Nothing wonderful will ever happen to me again. I had a perfect childhood in Charleston, Will. An incredible childhood full of rope swings and summer nights in hammocks and August regattas and debutante parties and climbing over the seawall on the Battery. But that’s all in the past now and will never happen again. That’s all finished and those times are dead.”
“Yeh, your life is over,” I said. “You must be all of twenty.”
“I’m nineteen. Don’t you make me older than I am. I won’t be twenty for three months.”
“It’s hard to tell how old you are when you always wear those sunglasses, that scarf, and that raincoat.”
“Do I make snide remarks about your silly uniform?” she replied. “Cadets all look like ice cream salesmen in those tacky summer uniforms.”
“I’m very sensitive about my uniform. It’s my outlandish loyalty at work again. No, I can explain why I wear my uniform, but I don’t understand why you wear yours.”
“I wear it because I’m in prison,” she answered.
“If you think this is a prison,” I said, gesturing around the garden, “let me show you the Institute sometime. But that’s not the point. I’m asking questions about the sunglasses, Annie Kate, for a very good reason. Someday before I get gouty and rheumatic and live in a nursing home, I’d like to see what your face looks like.”
“I’ve got a very pretty face,” she said simply.
“I’d like to see what color your eyes are and what color your hair is.”
“My eyes are of a very light blue. Not as light as yours, but my eyes aren’t as threatening as yours are. Not as empty. Your eyes don’t look inhabited.”
I laughed, a bit too loudly, for she put a finger to her lips and turned in the direction of the main house. All was silent in the garden when I spoke again. “You keep talking like that and I’m going to wear sunglasses. I’ve always been told I have very nice eyes. That’s the only thing people can think of when they try to say something nice about my face.”
“If I were you, Mr. McLean, I wouldn’t just wear sunglasses,” she said coyly. “I’d purchase a huge mask or perhaps a shopping bag.”
“You have a sharp tongue beneath those sunglasses.”
“I told you I was smart.”
Before I could answer another voice in the garden said, “Not that smart, my dear.”
The woman was smaller than I remembered her and much thinner. But it was not her diminutiveness that left the strongest impression on me; rather, it was a quality of beleaguered delicacy, as though her spirit had endured the same heedless inattention as her garden. There was something insufficient and untended about her. Her voice was troubled and defeated, all low sad tones like the scrupulous grief of cellos.
“Ma’am,” I said in the silence that followed the shock of her noiseless onslaught, “you are indeed a quiet little person.”
But her arrival held no real elements of surprise. The very artificiality of the secret meeting invited capture. The mother’s face was flushed with triumph and disapproval. Annie Kate had not looked up since she heard the other woman’s voice. The garden resonated with melancholy and shame, with betrayal and sin.
“You are on private property, young man, and if you don’t depart from these grounds at once, I will call the police and have you thrown in the city jail by the river. The Charleston city jail is famous for the size of its rats.”
“Mother, please,” Annie Kate moaned.
“I demand to know why you’re pursuing my daughter.”
“Mother!”
“What I’m doing, Annie Kate, I’m doing for you. You know that. You know that I don’t like it any better than you do, but you know that it’s absolutely necessary. This young man was not my idea. Remember that,” she said, turning her attention back to me. “Cadet, you are neither absolutely necessary nor even very desirable.”
“Ma’am, I did not just trip on a crack in the sidewalk on Church Street and accidentally land in this garden. I was invited here by Annie Kate, who appears to be badly in need of someone to talk to. She told me she needs a friend. I can be a good friend. I can also be discreet and if Annie Kate robbed a bank or molested chickadees in a bird sanctuary, I don’t care. If you don’t want anyone in Charleston to know that Annie Kate’s in town, then I won’t tell anyone. If you don’t want me to know why you’re acting like Annie Kate’s radioactive, then you don’t have to tell me. You have my word that I won’t tell another living soul that I’ve met either one of you.”
The older woman eyed me for a long time then asked her daughter, “Do you think you can
trust him, Annie Kate?”
“I don’t know,” she replied. “He’s got Catholic eyes.”
“My daughter is very lonely and very bored, Mr. McLean. That is partially my fault and partially hers.”
“Ma’am, if she’s leaving anonymous notes on cars of cadets, she’s more than bored.”
“I’m stark raving mad,” Annie Kate said, slumping down on the garden bench.
“Quit being silly, Annie Kate. You decide what to tell Mr. McLean. I’ll leave that all up to you. Since you’ve tried to prove what a grownup girl you are, you can decide if he comes back to this house or not. And Mr. McLean,” she said, fixing me with both the intensity and sadness of her gaze, “I’m holding you to your word of honor to speak of this with no one, not even your closest friends.”
“Yes, Ma’am. I promise.”
She disappeared down the brick pathway that led to the main house. Her walk was stiff, formal, and painfully graceless. As she left I became aware of a deep wild perfume exhumed in the rising heat of the day, lifting invisibly from the untrimmed hedges and grottoes of ill-disciplined flowers. The garden smelled like an abandoned florist’s shop. Annie Kate read the drift of my thoughts as I sat back upon the bench.
“We used to have a gardener,” she said. “Before my father died.”
“It looks like the gardener died, too.”
“Mother let him go several years ago. She said it was because of his drinking, but it was actually because we had no money.”
“You won’t be needing a gardener soon. They’ll be leading safaris through your back yard.”
“You have a very Irish face,” she said, observing me closely.
“Why don’t you say that I have a very sexy face?”
“You don’t have a very sexy face. You have a funny, sad clown’s face.”
“Women go wild over this face. They’re always knocking into each other trying to lay a pinkie on my face.”
“I want to be honest about this relationship from the very beginning.”