innocent bartender for both murders.
Billy had survived being a suspect once. The experience reshaped him. Profoundly.
He would resist being reshaped again. He had lost too much of himself the first time.
He left the cover of the plum tree. He quietly climbed the front-porch steps and went directly to the door.
The key worked. The hardware didn’t rattle, the hinges didn’t squeak, and the door opened silently.
chapter 11
THIS VICTORIAN HOUSE HAD A VICTORIAN foyer with a dark wood floor. A wood-paneled hall led toward the back of the house, and a staircase offered the upstairs.
On one wall had been taped an eight-by-ten sheet of paper on which had been drawn a hand. It looked like Mickey Mouse’s hand: a plump thumb, three fingers, and a wrist roll suggestive of a glove.
Two fingers were folded back against the palm. The thumb and forefinger formed a cocked gun that pointed to the stairs.
Billy got the message, all right, but he chose to ignore it for the time being.
He left the front door open in case he needed to make a quick exit.
Holding the revolver with the muzzle pointed at the ceiling, he stepped through an archway to the left of the foyer. The living room looked as it had when Mrs. Olsen had been alive, ten years ago. Lanny didn’t use it much.
The same was true of the dining room. Lanny ate most of his meals in the kitchen or in the den while watching TV.
In the hallway, taped to the wall, another cartoon hand pointed toward the foyer and the stairs, opposite from the direction in which he was proceeding.
Although the TV was dark in the den, flames fluttered in the gas-log fireplace, and in a bed of faux ashes, false embers glowed as if real.
On the kitchen table stood a bottle of Bacardi, a double-liter plastic jug of Coca-Cola, and an ice bucket. On a plate beside the Coke gleamed a small knife with a serrated blade and a lime from which a few slices had been carved.
Beside the plate stood a tall, sweating glass half full of a dark concoction. In the glass floated a slice of lime and a few thin slivers of melting ice.
After stealing the killer’s first note from Billy’s kitchen and destroying it with the second to save his job and his hope of a pension, Lanny had tried to drown his guilt with a series of rum and Cokes.
If the jug of Coca-Cola and the bottle of Bacardi had been full when he sat down to the task, he had made considerable progress toward a state of drunkenness sufficient to shroud memory and numb the conscience until morning.
The pantry door was closed. Although Billy doubted that the freak lurked in there among the canned goods, he wouldn’t feel comfortable turning his back on it until he investigated.
With his right arm tucked close to his side and the revolver aimed in front of him, he turned the knob fast and pulled the door with his left hand. No one waited in the pantry.
From a kitchen drawer, Billy removed a clean dishtowel. After wiping the metal drawer-pull and the knob on the pantry door, he tucked one end of the cloth under his belt and let it hang from his side in the manner of a bar rag.
On a counter near the cooktop lay Lanny’s wallet, car keys, pocket change, and cell phone. Here, too, was his 9-mm service pistol with the Wilson Combat holster in which he carried it.
Billy picked up the cell phone, switched it on, and summoned voice mail. The only message in storage was the one that he himself had left for Lanny earlier in the evening.
This is Billy. I’m at home. What the hell? What’ve you done? Call me now.
After listening to his own voice, he deleted the message.
Maybe that was a mistake, but he didn’t see any way that it could prove his innocence. On the contrary, it would establish that he had expected to see Lanny during the evening just past and that he had been angry with him.
Which would make him a suspect.
He had brooded about the voice mail during the drive to the church parking lot and during the walk through the meadow. Deleting it seemed the wisest course if he found what he expected to find on the second floor.
He switched off the cell phone and used the dishtowel to wipe it clean of prints. He returned it to the counter where he had found it.
If someone had been watching right then, he would have figured Billy for a calm, cool piece of work. In truth, he was half sick with dread and anxiety.
An observer might also have thought that Billy, judging by his meticulous attention to detail, had covered up crimes before. That wasn’t the case, but brutal experience had sharpened his imagination and had taught him the dangers of circumstantial evidence.
An hour previously, at 1:44, the killer had rung Billy from this house. The phone company would have a record of that brief call.
Perhaps the police would think it proved Billy couldn’t have been here at the time of the murder.
More likely, they would suspect that Billy himself had placed the call to an accomplice at his house for the misguided purpose of trying to establish his presence elsewhere at the time of the murder.
Cops always suspected the worst of everyone. Their experience had taught them to do so.
At the moment, he couldn’t think of anything to be done about the phone-company records. He put it out of his mind.
More urgent matters required his attention. Like finding the corpse, if one existed.
He didn’t think he should waste time searching for the killer’s two notes. If they were still intact, he would most likely have found them on the table at which Lanny had been drinking or on the counter with his wallet, pocket change, and cell phone.
The flames in the den fireplace, on this warm summer night, led to a logical conclusion about the notes.
Taped to the side of a kitchen cabinet was a cartoon hand that pointed to the swinging door and the downstairs hallway.
At last Billy was willing to take direction, but a shrinking, anxious fear immobilized him.
Possession of a firearm and the will to use it did not give him sufficient courage to proceed at once. He did not expect to encounter the freak. In some ways the killer would have been less intimidating than what he did expect to find.
The bottle of rum tempted him. He had felt no effect from the three bottles of Guinness. His heart had been thundering for most of an hour, his metabolism racing.
For a man who was not much of a drinker, he’d recently had to remind himself of that fact often enough to suggest that a potential rummy lived inside him, yearning to be free.
The courage to proceed came from a fear of failing to proceed and from an acute awareness of the consequences of surrendering this hand of cards to the freak.
He left the kitchen and followed the hall to the foyer. At least the stairs were not dark; there was light here below, at the landing, and at the top.
Ascending, he did not bother calling Lanny’s name. He knew that he would receive no answer, and he doubted that he could have found his voice anyway.
chapter 12
OPENING OFF THE UPPER HALLWAY WERE THREE bedrooms, a bathroom, and a closet. Four of those five doors were closed.
On both sides of the entrance to the master bedroom were cartoon hands pointing to that open door.
Reluctant to be herded, thinking of animals driven up a ramp at a slaughterhouse, Billy left the master bedroom for last. He first checked the hall bath. Then the closet and the two other bedrooms, in one of which Lanny kept a drawing table.
Using the dishtowel, he wiped all the doorknobs after he touched them.
With only the one space remaining to be searched, he stood in the hall, listening. No pin dropped.
Something had stuck in his throat, and he couldn’t swallow it. He couldn’t swallow it because it was no more real than the sliver of ice sliding down the small of his back.
He entered the master bedroom, where two lamps glowed.
The rose-patterned wallpaper chosen by Lanny’s mother had not been removed after she died and not even, a few
years later, after Lanny moved out of his old room into this one. Age had darkened the background to a pleasing shade reminiscent of a light tea stain.
The bedspread had been one of Pearl Olsen’s favorites: rose in color overall, with embroidered flowers along the borders.
Often during Mrs. Olsen’s illness, following chemotherapy sessions, and after her debilitating radiation treatments, Billy had sat with her in this room. Sometimes he just talked to her or watched her sleep. Often he read to her.
She had liked swashbuckling adventure stories. Stories set during the Raj in India. Stories with geishas and samurai and Chinese warlords and Caribbean pirates.
Pearl was gone, and now so was Lanny. Dressed in his uniform, he sat in an armchair, legs propped on a footstool, but he was gone just the same.
He had been shot in the forehead.
Billy didn’t want to see this. He dreaded having this image in his memory. He wanted to leave.
Running, however, was not an option. It never had been, neither twenty years ago nor now, nor any time between. If he ran, he would be chased down and destroyed.
The hunt was on, and for reasons he didn’t understand, he was the ultimate game. Speed of flight would not save him. Speed never saved the fox. To escape the hounds and the hunters, the fox needed cunning and a taste for risk.
Billy didn’t feel like a fox. He felt like a rabbit, but he would not run like one.
The lack of blood on Lanny’s face, the lack of leakage from the wound suggested two things: that death had been instantaneous and that the back of his skull had been blown out.
No bloodstains or brain matter soiled the wallpaper behind the chair. Lanny had not been drilled as he sat there, had not been shot anywhere in this room.
As Billy had not found blood elsewhere in the house, he assumed that the killing occurred outside.
Perhaps Lanny had gotten up from the kitchen table, from his rum and Coke, half drunk or drunk, needing fresh air, and had stepped outside. Maybe he realized that his aim wouldn’t be neat enough for the bathroom and therefore went into the backyard to relieve himself.
The freak must have used a plastic tarp or something to move the corpse through the house without making a mess.
Even if the killer was strong, getting the dead man from the backyard to the master bedroom, considering the stairs, would have been a hard job. Hard and seemingly unnecessary.
To have done it, however, he must have had a reason that was important to him.
Lanny’s eyes were open. Both bulged slightly in their sockets. The left one was askew, as if he’d had a cast eye in life.
Pressure. For the instant during which the bullet had transited the brain, pressure inside the skull soared before being relieved.
A book-club novel lay in Lanny’s lap, a smaller and more cheaply produced volume than the handsome edition of the same title that had been available in bookstores. At least two hundred similar books were shelved at one end of the bedroom.
Billy could see the title, the author’s name, and the jacket illustration. The story was about a search for treasure and true love in the South Pacific.
A long time ago, he had read this novel to Pearl Olsen. She had liked it, but then she had liked them all.
Lanny’s slack right hand rested on the book. He appeared to have marked his place with a photograph, a small portion of which protruded from the pages.
The psychopath had arranged all of this. The tableau satisfied him and had emotional meaning to him, or it was a message—a riddle, a taunt.
Before disturbing the scene, Billy studied it. Nothing about it seemed compelling or clever, nothing that might have excited the murderer enough to motivate him to put forth such effort in its creation.
Billy mourned Lanny; but with a greater passion, he hated that Lanny had been afforded no dignity even in death. The freak dragged him around and staged him as if he were a mannequin, a doll, as if he had existed only for the creep’s amusement and manipulation.
Lanny had betrayed Billy; but that didn’t matter anymore. On the edge of the Dark, on the brink of the Void, few offenses were worth remembering. The only things worth recalling were the moments of friendship and laughter.
If they had been at odds on Lanny’s last day, they were on the same team now, with the same and singular adversary.
Billy thought he heard a noise in the hall.
Without hesitation, holding the revolver in both hands, he left the master bedroom, clearing the doorway fast, sweeping the .38 left to right, seeking a target. No one.
The bathroom, closet, and other bedroom doors were closed, as he had left them.
He didn’t feel a pressing need to search those rooms again. He might have heard nothing but an ordinary settling noise as the old house protested the weight of time, but it almost certainly had not been the sound of a door opening or closing.
He blotted the damp palm of his left hand on his shirt, switched the gun to it, blotted his right hand, returned the gun to it, and went to the head of the stairs.
From the lower floor, from the porch beyond the open front door, came nothing but a summer-night silence, a dead-of-night hush.
chapter 13
AS HE STOOD AT THE HEAD OF THE STAIRS, LISTENING, pain had begun to throb in Billy’s temples. He realized that his teeth were clenched tighter than the jaws of a vise.
He tried to relax and breathe through his mouth. He rolled his head from side to side, working the stiffening muscles of his neck.
Stress could be beneficial if you used it to stay focused and alert. Fear could paralyze, but also sharpen the survival instinct.
He returned to the master bedroom.
Approaching the door, he suddenly thought body and book would be gone. But Lanny still sat in the armchair.
From a tissue box on one of the nightstands, Billy plucked two Kleenex. Using them as an impromptu glove, he moved the dead man’s hand off the book.
Leaving the book on the cadaver’s lap, he opened it to the place that had been marked by the photograph.
He expected sentences or paragraphs to have been highlighted in some fashion: a further message. But the text was pristine.
Still using the Kleenex, he picked up the photo, a snapshot.
She was young and blond and pretty. Nothing in the picture gave a clue to her profession, but Billy knew that she had been a teacher.
Her killer must have found this snapshot in her house, down in Napa. Before or after finding it, he brutally beat the beauty out of her.
No doubt the freak had left the photograph in the book to confirm for the authorities that the two murders had been the work of the same man. He was bragging. He wanted the credit that he had earned.
The only wisdom we can hope to acquire is the wisdom of humility….
The freak hadn’t learned that lesson. Perhaps his failure to learn it would lead to his fall.
If it was possible to feel genuinely heartbroken over the fate of a stranger, the photo of this young woman would have done the job had Billy stared at it too long. He returned it to the book and closed it in the yellowing pages.
After putting the dead man’s hand atop the book, as it had been, he wadded the two Kleenex in his fist. He went into the bathroom that was part of the master suite, pushed the plunger with the Kleenex, and then dropped them into the whirling water in the toilet bowl.
In the bedroom, he stood beside the armchair, not sure what he should do.
Lanny did not deserve to be left here alone without benefit of prayer or justice. If not a close friend, he had nevertheless been a friend. Besides, he was Pearl Olsen’s son, and that ought to count for a lot.
Yet to phone the sheriff’s department, even anonymously, and report the crime might be a mistake. They would want an explanation for the call that had been placed from this house to Billy’s place soon after the murder; and he still had not decided what to tell them.
Other issues, things he didn’t know about, might point the
finger of suspicion at him. Circumstantial evidence.
Perhaps the ultimate intention of the killer was to frame Billy for these murders and for others.
Undeniably, the freak saw this as a game. The rules, if any, were known only to him.
Likewise, the definition of victory was known only to him. Winning the pot, capturing the king, scoring the final touchdown might mean, in this case, sending Billy to prison for life not for any rational reason, not so the freak himself could escape justice, but for the sheer fun of it.
Considering that he could not even discern the shape of the playing field, Billy didn’t relish being interrogated by Sheriff John Palmer.
He needed time to think. A few hours at least. Until dawn.
“I’m sorry,” he told Lanny.
He switched off one of the bedside lamps and then the other.
If the house glowed like a centenarian’s birthday cake through the night, someone might notice. And wonder. Everyone knew Lanny Olsen was an early-to-bed guy.
The house stood at the highest and loneliest point of the dead-end lane. Virtually no one drove up here unless they were coming to see Lanny, and no one was likely to visit during the next eight or ten hours.
Midnight had turned Tuesday to Wednesday. Wednesday and Thursday were Lanny’s days off. No one would miss him at work until Friday.
Nevertheless, one by one, Billy returned to the other upstairs rooms and switched off those lights as well.
He doused the hall lights and went down the stairs, uneasy about all the darkness at his back.
In the kitchen, he closed the door to the porch and locked it.
He intended to take Lanny’s spare key with him.
As he went forward once more through the first floor, he turned off all the lights, including the ceramic gas-fueled logs in the den fireplace, using the barrel of the handgun to flip the switches.
Standing on the front porch, he locked that door as well, and wiped the knob.
He felt watched as he descended the steps. He surveyed the lawn, the trees, glanced back at the house.
All the windows were black, and the night was black, and Billy walked away from that closed darkness into an open darkness under an India-ink sky in which stars seemed to float, seemed to tremble.
chapter 14
HE WALKED BRISKLY DOWNHILL ALONG THE shoulder of the lane, ready to take cover in the roadside brush if headlights appeared.
Frequently, he glanced back. As far as he could tell, no one followed him.
Moonless, the night favored a stalker. It should have favored Billy, too, but he felt exposed by the stars.
At the house with the chest-high fence, the half-seen dog once more raced back and forth along the pickets, beseeching Billy with a whimper. It sounded desperate.
He sympathized with the animal and understood its condition. His plight,