Eloise stared at her. “I know he likes movies,” she said. “But—”
“He was really happy,” Kathleen said, also stepping up. “Honestly, if you had seen how happy Charlie was, eating his ice cream and talking about movies, you wouldn't have worried at all.”
“We just want him to have fun,” Sari said. “And to be part of something. The job would be at a video store, which you have to admit he'd love. He's so excited at the idea of it—”
“He doesn't know what could happen out there,” her mother said. “I know. I know how cruel the world can be, how vicious people are. And I thought you did, too.”
Jason put a gentle hand on her arm. “Give this a chance,” he said. “Sari just wants what's best for Charlie.”
“I’m his mother,” Eloise said. “I know what's best.”
“And I’m his sister,” Sari said. “I love him as much as you do.”
“I can't let him go out in the world unprotected. I can't. It would be like sending a lamb out to be eaten by wolves.”
“I think it's a good idea,” said a voice from behind them all. Everyone turned around. Sari's father was standing in the hallway that led to the back bedroom. “He should try getting a job like other men his age. Why not?”
“You don't know anything about this,” Eloise said.
“I know that grown men get jobs,” her husband said. “I’dlike to see my thirty-year-old son get up off the sofa and give it a try.”
Eloise opened her mouth to say something, but there were too many people circled around her, too many eyes watching her, too many faces waiting. She held up her hands, more like she was warding something off than in surrender. “If he gets hurt, it'll be your fault, Sari.”
“He won't get hurt,” Sari said. “Not this time.”
“We'll be looking out for him,” Jason said, guiding Eloise into a chair and down into a seated position. “I promise.”
She clutched at his arm. “You, at least, I trust,” she said. “You understand me.”
“Of course I do.” He knelt at her side. “We both know what it is to love a child with special needs and to want to do right by him.”
She burst into drunken tears and he stayed there, patting her shoulder, while the others busied themselves cleaning up and getting ready to go.
“And you call me a miracle worker,” Sari said to Jason a little while later, after they had said their goodbyes and left. They were all standing together in front of the house. “You were amazing with her.”
“Yeah, that was pretty impressive,” Lucy said. “Let's hope you only ever use your skills for good and not evil.”
“It wasn't bullshit,” Jason said. “I really do know how she feels. I mean, not the religious stuff, but the part about just wanting to keep Charlie safe at home. I get that.”
“So what now?” David said. “Want to go to the pound and make out with the dogs, Luce?”
“Sorry,” she said. “Can't.” She indicated the other two girls. “It's knitting time.”
“No, it's not,” he said. “It's the afternoon.”
“That's because we had to come here first,” she said. “We switched it around.”
Jason looked at Sari. She smiled apologetically. “Sorry,” she said. “Just for a couple of hours, okay? I’ll be back in time for dinner.”
Jason picked up Zack and said, “Looks like we're on our own for a while.”
“Do you mind driving David home?” Lucy asked him. “So I can take the girls in my car?”
“No problem.”
The men watched the girls pile into Lucy's car.
“Ever feel extraneous?” David said. “I mean, if Lucy didn't need someone to feed the cat when she's out of town—”
“Can't get in the way of their knitting circle,” Jason said. He hoisted Zack up onto his shoulders. “I’ve learned not to try. Anyway, girls like these are worth waiting around for, right?”
“Yeah,” David said, but not completely happily.
They lifted their hands to wave in unison as the car drove by them.
The girls didn't even notice. They were too busy talking and laughing.
III
Istill can't believe you're knitting an afghan,” Sari said to Kathleen, reaching across the table to touch the yarn. “It's so unlike you to be knitting something warm.”
“And brown,” Lucy added.
Since it was already late afternoon, they had decided to flout custom altogether and take their knitting out to a bar. They had scored a small table, which held their drinks and some of their knitting paraphernalia, and their knitting bags were on the floor at their feet, the skeins of wool coiling up along their legs to the needles they held. The guys who were crowded in front of the TV watching football and drinking beer had given them some strange looks when they first got settled, but they didn't care.
“Isn't it nice?” Kathleen said, lifting the needles up high so they could see the afghan in all its glory.
“Who's it for?” Lucy asked.
“Me, of course. I don't knit for anyone else. You know that.”
“But it's so unsexy,” Lucy said. “Unless … You're planning on lying under it naked and surprising someone, aren't you?”
“I doubt it,” Kathleen said. “There's no one worth being naked for these days.”
“Speak for yourself.”
“I am.” Kathleen put down her needles and took a sip of her drink. “Believe me, I’m well aware that of the three of us, I’m the only one going home to an empty bed tonight. It's like the world has turned upside down—everyone's having sex but me.
“I’m sorry, Kathleen,” Sari said. “It's not fair.”
“Yeah, it is.” She wrapped a strand of yarn around her index finger. “It's totally fair. This whole thing with Sam … It's my fault and I know it. I said some really stupid things about wanting to marry Kevin for his money.” She tugged the yarn off her finger and slumped down in her seat. “You guys are supposed to be my friends. Why didn't you stop me from going around saying stupid shit like that?”
“We stopped you from getting married to someone you didn't love,” Sari said. “Don't we get credit for that?”
“Keeping you from ever doing anything stupid would be a full-time job,” Lucy said. “And you're old enough to know that you can't go around telling people you're going after guys for their money and not expect it to bite you in the ass sooner or later.”
“But people shouldn't have to pay forever for stupid things they said and did in the past,” Sari said. “Look at Jason—he did far worse things than Kathleen—at least, I think he did—and here I am kind of madly in love with him. People deserve second chances.”
“You gave Jason a second chancebecause you were madly in love with him,” Lucy said. “The madly in love part came first.”
“So what are you saying?” Kathleen said. “That Sam just didn't like me enough to give me a second chance?”
“That's not what I meant.”
“Yes, it is. You're saying that if Sam had been madly in love with me, he would have forgiven me.”
“I don't know the guy,” Lucy said. “I don't know how his mind works.”
“I do,” Kathleen said. “He's not the kind of guy who gives people second chances. I actually think he was sort of in love with me, in his own way. I can tell when a guy's not interested—and that's not the problem. He just doesn't trust me.”
“It's his loss,” Sari said. “You'll find someone better. You could snap your fingers and have any guy in this room right now.”
Kathleen looked around. “Yeah,” she said. “I probably could.” There was a pause and then she wearily gathered the needles back up in her hands and resumed her knitting while Lucy and Sari exchanged worried looks above her bent head.
IV
When they were saying good night, Sari reminded Kathleen that she had to clean out her apartment. “You cant just leave your stuff there forever.”
“I won't.”
/> “It'll just get harder and harder to go back.”
“I know,” Kathleen said.
“Make the break,” Sari said. “I want to see you happy again, Kath. And I don't think you will be until you're completely out of there.”
“You're right.” Kathleen fished her car keys out of her purse. “Maybe I’ll just run by there tonight. Just throw everything in the car and then find a way to let Sam know I’ve moved out.”
Sari checked her watch. “Want me to come with you?”
“Nah. Jason and Zack are waiting for you.”
“I can call them—”
“No, don't. I’m fine. I’m just going to run in there, get my stuff, and leave. A clean break, like you say.”
“Good,” Sari said. “And then you'll be able to move on. You'll have a new job, a new place to live—”
“My old job, my old place to live …”
“It's still a new beginning in its own way.”
Kathleen shrugged.
Sari hugged and released her. “I’m sorry things suck right now.”
“My own fault.” She trudged toward her car, her head down. “Hey,” Sari called. “You really okay?”
Kathleen turned to look at her. “Totally. Nothing gets me down for long. I’m tough.” She squared her shoulders. “I’m morethan tough. I’m Xena, the warrior princess. And I don't need no fucking costume to prove it.” She threw her head back and gave a passable Xena cry. People in the parking lot turned to look at her. “See?” she said. “See how tough I am?”
“You're a nut,” Sari said and got into her own car.
Kathleen watched Sari drive away. Even the car looked like it couldn't wait to get where it was going.
Kathleen herself was in no such rush. She took her time on the drive over to the apartment building, uncharacteristically gliding to a stop at every yellow light and staying well within the speed limit. She dreaded walking back into the apartment she had fled from, but Sari was right—it was time to clean it out and move on.
The doorman and elevator man greeted her with uncharacteristic warmth. “Haven't seen you around here much lately,” the first said. The elevator man actually smiled at her. “Good to see you again,” he said, before closing the door and taking her up to her floor.
Once she was inside the apartment, Kathleen looked around it with disgust. What was this place that she had lived in for several months? It could have been nice—it was big and pretty and well built—and instead it was a graveyard for balls and goals and dirty clothing and half-filled air mattresses. She hadn't even tried to make it livable. What was wrong with her? Why did everything good evade her touch, leaving her with nothing to call her own? Why did other people's lives fall into place and never hers?
She threw herself down on the air mattress in the living room and stared up at the ceiling. She never wanted to move again, just wanted to lie there forever in the peaceful quiet of the empty room, wallowing in self-loathing and misery.
Unfortunately for that plan, a loud banging started up somewhere in the building. She was getting more and more annoyed about it, when she realized it was coming from her own kitchen.
For someone who was never going to move again, she jumped up quickly enough. She ran, even, into the kitchen and flung the door open.
Sam was there, in gray pants and a white button-down shirt. No tie or jacket tonight. “Hello, Kathleen,” he said. “Do you have a moment?”
She stared at him. He seemed very calm, but then she noticed that one of his hands was opening and closing spasmodically at his side. The last time they'd spoken was when she had gotten off the elevator after their fight. “Yeah, I guess,” she said and took a step back.
“Thank you.” He entered and she let the door close behind him with a click.
“What do you want?” she said.
“I heard you come in.”
She waited.
“You haven't been here for a while. I was thinking maybe I should be worried.”
“I’m fine. As you can see.”
“I’m glad,” he said. Then, “I was hoping you'd come back. I thought maybe we should talk.”
“Really?” she said. “Because I feel like we wrapped things up pretty well last time I saw you. You pretty much answered any remaining questions I might have had with that get-the-hell-out-of-my-apartment shit.”
“I was angry,” he said. “But I’ve been waiting for you to come back, hoping maybe we could—”
“I’m only here to grab my stuff. In two hours, this apartment will be all yours again.”
“You don't have to move out.”
“I don't?” she said. “Weren't you planning on throwing me out anyway? Or is that the problem—I’m ruining all of your fun?”
“Kathleen—”
“Huh,” she said, leaning back against the counter. “Are you still here?”
He let out a deep breath. “I know you re not the world's greatest listener, but could you maybe just try for once?”
She looked at her fingernails. “It's not that I can't listen so much as it is that I’m not interested.”
“Pretend I’m talking about shoes.”
“Shoes?” she repeated. “How fucking shallow do you think I am?” She turned and walked out of the kitchen.
He followed her. “I’m sorry,” he said. “I didn't mean it that way. I was just trying to—” He stopped. “I’m sorry,” he said again. “But will you please just listen to me for a second?”
“Okay, fine,” she said. “What?”
He pushed his hand through his hair. His fingers were shaking. “I’m still trying to figure things out,” he said. “I didn't want to get hurt. I still don't.” She stayed silent. Then he said, “But I miss you when you're not around. It's been way too quiet around here, way too lonely. Unbearable even. You're like—” He opened his hands. “You're like a pet—company when I want company, so long as I don't mind a few stains on the rug and couch.”
“Jesus,” she said. “I’m not a fucking cat, Sam.”
“No,” he said. “I was thinking more a dog. Cats are very clean.”
She turned her back on him, took a step away, then whirled back around. “You know what? We're both idiots.”
“Okay,” he said.
“We're both idiots,” she repeated. “We've just been taking turns at it. Sometimes I talk too much and say things I don't mean. And when I said that I wanted to marry Kevin and be rich forever, I didn't mean it. Because—” There was no way to say it and make herself look good. So she didn't even try. “Because I’ve never known what to do with myself. I have nothing I want to do and nothing I’m good at. So sometimes I just try things out to see if they fit. And I thought maybe going after money was a sign of—I don't know, maturity or something. So I tried it out. Tried to be—what's the word? When all you care about is money?”
“Mercenary?”
She nodded. “Yeah, that's it. I tried being mercenary. And it didn't fit. I’m a flake and I put my foot in it all the time and I can be a pig when I eat—”
“I’ve noticed.”
“I’m a pig and all those other things, but I’m not mercenary, Sam. If I were, I’d have married Kevin in Hawaii like I was supposed to.”
“You were supposed to get married?” he said.
“But I didn't.”
He smiled weakly. “I wouldn't call that one of your strongest selling points at the moment—that you were engaged to be married to someone else a couple of months ago.”
“It is, though,” Kathleen said. “I didn't marry Kevin, not because I couldn't but because I didn't want to. Doesn't that prove I don't just care about money?”
“It doesn't change the fact that I’m rich. And I can't quite see what other charms I’m likely to hold for someone like you.” He gave a twisted smile. “I’m well aware you could have any man you wanted.”
She took a step toward him. “Sam—”
He held his hands up, holding her off. “I don'
t want to be anyone's sugar daddy, Kathleen.” He looked at the floor and then back up at her again. “You have no idea how scared I am of becoming something like that.”
“If it makes you feel better,” she said, “you're not the sugar daddy type. I mean, if I wanted someone to take care of me and buy me things, I’d find someone who's actually nice to me. Isn't that kind of the point of a sugar daddy?”
“The money's the point.”
“I don't want your money, Sam. I don't even need it—I’ve started working for my sisters again.”
“That can't pay very well.”
“Well enough,” she said. “Well enough that if it would help you learn to trust me, I could pay my half of anything.”
He gestured around them. “This apartment costs two point five million dollars.”
“Well, not that, obviously. Anyway, I’m living with my sisters again. I just meant I can pay for my meals. And movies and stuff like that.”
“You think that will solve the problem?”
“Fuck it, Sam,” she said, flinging her right hand out. “Either you believe that I’m not just after your money or you don't. What else can I say?”
He studied her for a moment. “You're right,” he said finally “And I do believe you. Maybe it's a mistake, but I do. So where does that leave us?”
She was silent for a moment. Then she said, “I don't know.” She took another step toward him. “But if I were a dog, I’d be a stray. I have nowhere to go, no place to call my own—just be nice to me and I’ll probably follow you home.”
“But what if this is something else you're just trying out? Going after—” He shook his head. “Christ, I don't even know how to define what this might be. But what if you realize this—whatever it is—doesn't fit, either? What if you follow someone else home one day?”
“It's a risk,” she said.
“I don't know if it's one I want to take.”
Her mouth curved up in something that wasn't a smile. “Then get a golden retriever. He'll be yours for life.”
“They shed.” He took another deep breath. “Look, Kathleen, I don't expect anything permanent. And I don't want any promises. I’ve already been through that whole until-death-do-us-part thing and the fact that I’m here with you right now proves how meaningless those promises are. But I’ve been protecting myself for a while. To put myself out there again—with someone with your kind of track record—knowing how badly I could get hurt—” He stopped and said again, “I don't want any promises. But I need some sense of the risk/gain ratio. How much time am I likely to have?”