A tiny gasp slipped from Avery's lips when I spun her around. The passenger door of my car popped as I pressed her against it, and she startled. We both laughed, and then I dipped down to capture another taste of her mouth, relishing in her sweetness.
I reluctantly pulled back, wondering if it was this way with everyone. The more time I spent with her, the more beautiful she was. I pressed my forehead against hers, hoping to never wake up from this dream. Heavy drops of rain began to fall on us, breaking the magic of the moment. Avery laughed and looked up. I scrambled to gather Mrs. Cipriani's belongings, and then Avery joined me. Our laughter grew louder with each item we put away.
"Here," I said, handing her the box. I reached up, unhooking the glass balls from the pine tree and tossing them gently. She beamed as she moved the box to catch each one.
After the final decoration was packed, I took back the box and kissed her forehead. "Hot cocoa sounds pretty great," she whispered. The air had cooled with the rain, and her hair and dress were sticking to her skin.
I brushed a damp, golden strand away from her eyes. "Let's go."
My stomach was in knots by the time I pulled up to Avery's building. She hadn't spoken the entire trip back to her place. I wasn't sure if she was having doubts about me coming inside, and a guy like me shouldn't chance assumptions with a woman like Avery.
Parking on the side of the road, I hurried to her side of the car and pulled the door open. She smiled shyly as she slipped from the seat, pushing down the silky fabric of her dress.
I could see the nerves eating away at her, so I slipped my fingers between hers, squeezing her hand gently as she led me into her building and up the stairs, guiding me to her door. Fumbling with her keys, she nearly fell as the thick metal gave way and she lunged forward.
"It sticks," she mumbled while I closed it behind me.
"I can fix that for you."
She blushed. "You don't have to do that."
"I want to."
I took a step closer to her, sliding my hands against her warm cheeks and pulling her face to mine. Her body stiffened, but as my lips met hers, she relaxed against me. She slid her hands up my chest, and I sucked in a breath, feeling the sensation of her warm palms pressing the damp fabric into my skin. I wanted to feel her flesh against mine as I explored every dip and curve of her petite frame.
Gripping my shirt from the back of the collar, I pulled it over my head and tossed it to the ground. Avery's eyes danced down my torso as her fingers ran over the tattooed stripes on my ribs. Her brows pulled together, and I could see questions forming on her lips, but I didn't want this moment to end. We had plenty of time to talk later. In that moment, I just wanted to fully enjoy every second without distraction before she came to her senses and realized she deserved so much better than someone like me.
Slipping my fingers to the back of her neck, I slowly pulled at the knotted purple fabric until it became slack and fell loose. I could feel goose bumps rising on her skin as I let the pad of my finger slide down her spine. Her lips turned rigid, and then she pulled away. Her hands shot up, holding her dress in place over her chest as she took a step back from me.
I reached out for her. "Jesus, Avery. I didn't mean to--" Too fast. I always move too fucking fast. The girls I typically spent time with after dark didn't care how many hours we had known each other before my hand was under their clothes, but I knew better with Avery. She didn't need to let me fuck her in hopes it would keep me coming back long enough to feel something. I was the one hoping for more time.
"No. It's fine. I mean, you ..." Her voice wavered as she raked her hair back with her free hand.
Closing the gap between us, I wrapped my hand around hers and pulled it down to her side before reaching back to retie her halter top.
She didn't look away, but she breathed through her nose, crushed under her embarrassment.
I pulled the fabric until it caught, and then held the soft skin of her cheeks in my hands. "I don't expect anything, Avery. Not a fucking thing. Tonight was perfect, and if it ends here, we have ..." Forever. "... plenty of time. I don't want to rush if it'll ruin anything." I wasn't sure if it would be ballsy or stupid to tell her how I really felt, but tomorrow seemed too small for what I wanted from Avery. Even forever felt like it could crash down around us. Every second I wasn't with her was beginning to feel stretched, tearing gashes into the fabric of space and time.
"That sounds dangerously close to you planning to stick around a while." She attempted to smile, but failed.
"Hey." I lifted her chin. "You can talk to me."
"I'm just ..." She sighed, her smile fading as she struggled. "I've seen the women you chase, Josh. I'm not like that. I ..." She trailed off, wincing with humiliation.
It took a moment to wipe the confusion from my face while I tried to process her words. I laughed once. "Thank Christ. That's what I like about you, Avery." Caressing her jawline with my thumb, I watched as the rosy color of her cheeks deepened.
"I probably haven't done ... a lot of things," she said.
I shook my head, failing to stifle a laugh. Her expression turned from worried to pissed off. She pulled away from me, and I was learning quickly that I hated that.
"You're laughing at me?" she snapped.
"No. Jesus, Avery. Is that what you're worried about? A lot of this is new to me too, y'know. I'd rather be your first. And if I can't be your first in something ..." I gritted my teeth, willing myself to grow a pair.
"What?"
Her anger fizzled, but the worry in her eyes had returned. I would have to choose my words carefully. If I seemed like the old Josh, she was going to bolt. If I told her the truth, she was going to bolt too.
"No," I said with a sigh. "I'm trying to tell you that I ... I'm just going to fucking say it. I care about you, okay? And that is new to me and fucking terrifying. And I'm not really sure what to do if you don't feel the same way."
Her lips parted and she sucked in a tiny breath. After an eternity, she finally spoke. "I do. Feel the same, I mean."
"Yeah?" I asked, relief making my shoulders sink.
She nodded. "It scares me too. But something about us is different. I want this. I want you."
My eyebrows pulled together and I exhaled. My mouth crashed into hers, as if she were the only source of oxygen in a burning building. I wanted to be consumed by the inferno now raging between us.
The fabric of her dress fell away, and I scanned every soft curve of her skin. The only sound in the room was our breaths; the only movement was the reflection in her eyes as she watched me reach for her. I lifted her effortlessly, wrapping her legs around my waist. She kept her mouth on mine as I walked across the living room to the bedroom doorway. Reluctantly, I lowered her to the ground, until she was standing on her toes.
"What's wrong?" she asked.
"Something new for me."
"Which is?"
"A bedroom."
Avery bit her lip and giggled as I slowly slipped a hand behind her, fumbling with the small clasp of her bra before it snapped free and slid down to her waist. She broke her hold on me just long enough to toss the lace to the floor before pressing her body tight against mine.
My dick was painfully hard against the rough fabric of my jeans, but I didn't want to rush things with Avery. Her hands slid tentatively over the ridges of my abdomen, and they involuntarily flexed under her touch.
"Josh," she whispered against my lips as her fingers slipped under the waistband of my jeans. I quickly undid the button and zipper before shoving the denim to the ground and kicking them off my feet.
Giggling into my mouth, Avery gripped my shoulders. I lowered her back onto her bed, our bodies tangling in the mass of fluffy comforter beneath us.
There was no urgency between us. I wanted to savor every taste of her skin, from the valley above her collarbone to the soft curve of her breast.
I kissed my way down her stomach as it dipped and raised with her ragged breaths,
her long, elegant fingers lost in my hair, guiding me lower.
Pressing my lips to the pale pink lace adorned by a small matching bow on the front of her panties, I felt her body tense. My rough, calloused fingers tugged at the edge of the fabric, sliding it down over her hips and the widening of her thighs. I dragged them down to her painted toes and tossed them into the darkness. I considered kissing the apex of her thighs, but I climbed my way back up her body, desperate to feel her beneath me.
Even though Avery was significantly shorter than I was, her legs seemed impossibly long as they crossed behind my backside to hold me tighter against her. Her soft lips, still sticky from gloss, settled on a patch of skin just below my ear. I grew harder as I rocked my hips, moving my length along her inner thighs.
She breathed in and then let out a sexy, soft moan.
I tensed. "You keep that up, this will be over before we even start," I joked, and she rewarded me with one of her soft giggles, a whisper's breath blowing against my ear.
Pressing my cheek against hers, I closed my eyes. I needed a moment to calm myself before I lost control and flipped her ass over to take her in one of the many dirty ways I'd dreamed about since we'd spoken at JayWok. Avery deserved better than that. With her, I wanted more than just a quick, dirty fuck. I wanted to look into her eyes. For the first time, it was just as important to see the expression on her face when I slid inside her as the sensation itself.
"Don't move," I said, more begging than warning. I crawled from her body and fumbled with the button of my jeans at the side of the bed.
I said a silent prayer, followed by a thank-you when a small foil packet fell from my pocket into my hand. It bothered me that it had been placed in my wallet with the intention of being used on any random girl I took home. Now, I couldn't imagine this moment with anyone but Avery. I couldn't have predicted us being there, in Avery's bedroom, but it didn't stop the guilt from consuming me. Even watching me behave like the kind of douchebag she hated, Avery Jacobs was somehow lying beneath me, completely naked and impatiently waiting for me to make love to her. Everything had somehow fallen into place, even though I knew the truth: my life had been a series of bad luck. It was just a matter of time before Avery walked away.
I tore the corner of the packet with my teeth, and Avery's hand wrapped around mine, stopping me. My heart sank, as if she could see through the facade. Did she just now realize she was making a mistake? That she was settling?
Taking the small packet from my hand, she pushed gently against my chest, guiding me back onto her pillow. Her smooth thighs straddled mine as I watched in awe, willing myself to be patient. Eager women didn't require a lot of self-control. I knew the purpose and the end result, and I'd always accomplished that. Letting Avery set the pace was so different from what I was used to, and arousing in itself.
I couldn't help but run my fingers along her silky flesh as she took the condom from the packet and rolled it down my length. I didn't think it would be possible to be any more turned on, but Avery smiled in a way I'd never seen before, her mouth only half turned up, mischievous, ready. She skimmed my stomach with her lips, tasting my skin in a dozen small kisses. As soon as protection was in place, I grabbed Avery's waist and flipped her onto her back, settling in between her thighs. I couldn't wait any longer. I needed to be inside her.
Without looking away, Avery sucked in a sharp breath. I pressed against her entrance, painfully slow, allowing her to adjust to my size. The bite of her fingernails into my flesh let me know this moment was real, and this girl I had dreamed of was now mine. The room was quiet, aside from the mattress shifting with my movements, our ragged breathing, and small whimpers from Avery's lips as I filled her completely.
"Are you okay?" I asked, already breathing hard.
She nodded as my lips found hers. Relief washed over me, knowing she wanted this as much as I did and feeling the trust we had given each other. For the first time--at least, for me--sex was more than just sex. I'd never allowed myself to be that vulnerable with anyone. It was terrifying, and exhilarating, much more than any one-night stand I'd ever had.
I eased back and then filled her again. My movements were slow, matching the pace of our kiss. I wasn't used to being so gentle. I was afraid the perfect image of Avery would break and dissipate beneath me, leaving me in a crumbled heap of regrets and past mistakes.
Her pelvis tilted to meet mine as she mumbled my name against my lips. With my forehead resting against hers, I saw the only thing still between us: a small penny pinned between our chests.
Our panting mingled and became deafeningly loud in the small space as Avery shook beneath me, our bodies coated in a thin layer of sweat.
I leaned down, kissing her hard, feeling the build. My intended lovemaking was turning into fucking, and Avery welcomed the pounding rhythm.
Her soft cries of pleasure pushed me over the edge, and I thrust into her one last time before growling my release. We both stilled, struggling to catch our breath.
I brushed her slicked hair from her face, tracing my thumb over the arch of her eyebrow. I slowly eased out of her, seeing the disappointment in her eyes mirror mine.
"If I add sex to my list of things I hate, can we do that again?" An impish grin spread across her face.
"That was you hating sex? What are you like when you're enjoying yourself?" I leaned down to pepper her cheek and neck with kisses, finally settling on her lips.
Avery exhaled, suddenly seeming vulnerable and embarrassed. I touched her cheek, trying to think of something to remind her I was different.
"Is it lame for me to ask to see you again right now?"
She relaxed, settling against the mattress. She shook her head, pursing her lips to ask when. Before the word slipped from her lips, I said, "As soon as possible. Tomorrow. In the morning. Actually ... is it cool that I just stay?"
"You want to stay the night?"
I shrugged. "Waking up next to you sounds pretty fucking amazing."
She pretended to think about it for a few moments and then leaned up to peck my lips. "Yes."
I scanned her eyes for a moment and then rolled off Avery and made my way to her bathroom to dispose of the condom.
Flipping on the bathroom light, my eyes instinctively squinted at the intrusion. I bent over the sink, splashing cold water on my face, avoiding my own reflection. Small hands slid around my waist from behind, causing me to jump.
Avery's reflection appeared in the mirror, her hair disheveled and sexy, her mascara smudged below her emerald eyes. Long, elegant fingers ran over my striped tattoo, and my muscles tensed as her nail dragged over the fresh ink.
"That looks new."
"It is. Still a little tender. I actually got it because of you." The moment the words tumbled from my mouth, I closed my eyes tight and gritted my teeth. What the fuck, Josh? Why would you open that can?
I leaned against the edge of the porcelain sink and reached out for her, trying to play off what I'd said.
She stiffened in my arms. "Me? This isn't like a line for each person you've ..." She covered her face. "You were so sure this would happen that you already ... oh, God."
It took a moment to understand why she would be embarrassed. I leaned back, but she wouldn't look at me. "Avery. What are you ...?" When the realization hit, I frowned. "Jesus, it isn't some kind of tally to show who I've slept with. I'd have to be one cocky son of a bitch to get a tattoo before I'd even slept with you."
She peeked at me through her fingers and then dropped them from her face. "Then why is that--" she pointed at my side "--because of me?"
It suddenly felt hard to breathe, and I stiffened when she touched the stripes again. The truth was weighing heavily on me. What would Avery think when she heard about my past? She had a right to know, at least partially, where I had come from. Now that I had opened my big fucking mouth about it, there was no turning back. Avery knew she was involved, I'd just fucking told her, and she would want to know. She deserved to kno
w if she was going to chance being with me.
My mouth felt dry, and I swallowed back a couple decades of insecurity and anger. Kayla had died because of me, and it was my fault our family had fallen apart. My parents still hadn't forgiven me. How could I expect Avery to understand?
She reached out to my bare hips and pulled me toward her, looking up. "Talk to me," she said, quoting me from earlier in the evening.
I cleared my throat. "How much alcohol do you have?"
With my hair in knots and my insides wonderfully sore, I stretched in bed, the floor peppered with tossed undergarments. My apartment was familiar but unfamiliar. The sheets smelled like a sweet combination of my lotion, Josh's cologne, spilled cheap wine, and sex. I glimpsed at the clock, grateful it was my day off.
Josh was gone. I wasn't sure what time his shift had begun, but he had warned me before I asked him to stay that he wasn't so lucky.
I reached for his pillow that was once the spare, hugged it to my chest, and rolled onto my back, looking up at the ceiling. Every detail from the previous night replayed in my mind: the way his shoes sounded against my floor, the way his skin tasted, how his hands felt on the parts of me no one else had touched in quite a while. I remembered the glorious pressure of his fingertips digging into my skin, the filling sensation when he had slid inside me, his stomach gliding against mine with every thrust, his arms tensing, and the sound he had made when he came. My thighs tensed. I'd wanted the night to last forever, and I wanted to go back and do it all over again.
I let go of his pillow and rolled out of bed, trudging to the bathroom. The pipes rattled and whined when I turned the knob of the tiny shower. I paused, looking down into the trash can. A used condom. The soap dish had been moved. Droplets of water in the sink. Someone else had occupied the space of my apartment. It was strangely exhilarating.
I stepped under the water, for a moment mourning that I was washing away of any evidence that Josh had made himself at home against my skin. We had been tangled together for a night. We had gone from practically strangers to lovers in the span of a month--since the accident.